Re: emoji props in the ucdxml ?

2017-07-06 Thread Daniel Bünzli via Unicode
Ken, 

Thanks for your explanations. 

I would just like to note that UAX42 expresses a general xml data format to 
associate properties to code points. So it would be possible for the standard 
maintainers to publish, independently from the UCD, alongside the ad-hoc text 
files, xml files that have the properties.

Best, 

Daniel

P.S. I don't have a particular obsession or love with XML but when I started to 
implement bits of the standard a few years ago I apparently made the mistake to 
think that the UTC would eventually move away from creating ad-hoc text files 
and favour the structured data format of the ucdxml. So most of my 
implementation pipeline is geared at consuming character properties from these 
files.





Re: emoji props in the ucdxml ?

2017-07-05 Thread Ken Whistler via Unicode

Manuel,

I suspect that such a link may already be in the works for the 
/Public/emoji/ data directory. But if you want to make sure your 
suggestion is reviewed by the UTC, you should submit it via the contact 
form:


http://www.unicode.org/reporting.html

--Ken

On 7/5/2017 12:37 PM, Manuel Strehl via Unicode wrote:

but are there any plans to integrate the data in the ucdxml [2]
(possibly as separate files) ?

No. Not unless and until they become formally part of the UCD.

In this context: Would it be possible for the maintainers of the TR #51
data files to add a symlink "latest" under
unicode.org/Public/emoji/latest like there is for the UCD? That would be
a tremendous time saver, at least for me, having a constant URL to fetch
the latest Emoji data from.

Who should I ask for such a link?

Cheers,
Manuel





Re: emoji props in the ucdxml ?

2017-07-05 Thread Manuel Strehl via Unicode

>> but are there any plans to integrate the data in the ucdxml [2]
>> (possibly as separate files) ?
>
> No. Not unless and until they become formally part of the UCD.

In this context: Would it be possible for the maintainers of the TR #51
data files to add a symlink "latest" under
unicode.org/Public/emoji/latest like there is for the UCD? That would be
a tremendous time saver, at least for me, having a constant URL to fetch
the latest Emoji data from.

Who should I ask for such a link?

Cheers,
Manuel


Re: emoji props in the ucdxml ?

2017-07-05 Thread Ken Whistler via Unicode


On 7/5/2017 10:01 AM, Daniel Bünzli via Unicode wrote:

I know the emoji properties [1] are no formally part of the UCD (not sure 
exactly why though),


Because they are maintained as part of an independent standard now (UTS 
#51), which is still on track to have a faster turnaround -- and hence 
faster data updates -- not synched with the annual versions of the 
Unicode Standard. Hence they cannot be formally a part of the UCD -- 
unless the entire Unicode Standard were going to be churned on a faster 
cycle as well.



but are there any plans to integrate the data in the ucdxml [2] (possibly as 
separate files) ?


No. Not unless and until they become formally part of the UCD.

--Ken