VNodes, Replication and Minimum cluster size

2013-01-10 Thread Ryan Lowe
I have heard before that the recommended minimum cluster size is 4 (with replication factor of 3). I am curious to know if vnodes would change that or if that statement was valid to begin with! The use case I am working on is one where we see tremendous amount of load for just 2 days out of the

Re: VNodes, Replication and Minimum cluster size

2013-01-10 Thread Alain RODRIGUEZ
I am curious to know if vnodes would change that or if that statement was valid to begin with! This question was answered yesterday by Jonathan Ellis during the Datastax C*ollege Webinar: http://www.datastax.com/resources/webinars/whatsnewincassandra12 (about the end of the video). The answer is

Re: VNodes, Replication and Minimum cluster size

2013-01-10 Thread Sam Overton
On 10 January 2013 13:07, Ryan Lowe ryanjl...@gmail.com wrote: I have heard before that the recommended minimum cluster size is 4 (with replication factor of 3). I am curious to know if vnodes would change that or if that statement was valid to begin with! The reason that RF=3 is recommended

Re: VNodes, Replication and Minimum cluster size

2013-01-10 Thread Alain RODRIGUEZ
The key advantage of vnodes in this case is that you do not need to manually rebalance the cluster when adding or removing nodes. Well, I thing that a bigger key advantage of vnodes would rather be the performance improvement due to the evenly distributed load while streaming data. But it indeed