Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-13 Thread Werner Punz
David Steinkopff schrieb: OK, and what way can LGPLv3 combine with ALv2? That its the license question about JBoss and MyFaces. Well I assume, as always, the Apache license is a bsdish license which means everyone can use the code as long as some rules are followed (keep the headers intact in

Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-11 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
where did u read it ? On 6/11/07, David Steinkopff [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I read LGPLv3/GPLv3 will be compatible with Apache License 2.0. Its in that case possible to include dependencies to LGPLv3 code? regards David 2007/6/10, Martin Marinschek [EMAIL PROTECTED]: No, we cannot include

Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-11 Thread David Steinkopff
http://www.zdnet.com.au/news/software/soa/GPL-likely-to-regain-Apache-compatibility/0,130061733,339276229,00.htm(english) http://radar.oreilly.com/archives/2007/04/gplv3_apache_li.html (english) http://www.heise.de/open/news/meldung/90483 (german) for example regards David 2007/6/11, Matthias

Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-11 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
from the oreilly radar: snip It will be possible to merge code under those licenses into GPL3 covered software once the GPL version 3 is really out. /snip That reads like GPL3 code can contain Apache/Eclipse licensed code. Not that Apache code can contain GPL3. Here is an interesting comment,

Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-11 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
here is my email to legal. http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/www-legal-discuss/200706.mbox/[EMAIL PROTECTED] The reply isn't archived yet, but will be in some minutes, from now. On 6/11/07, Matthias Wessendorf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: from the oreilly radar: snip It will be possible

Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-11 Thread David Steinkopff
OK, and what way can LGPLv3 combine with ALv2? That its the license question about JBoss and MyFaces. 2007/6/11, Matthias Wessendorf [EMAIL PROTECTED]: here is my email to legal. http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/www-legal-discuss/200706.mbox/[EMAIL PROTECTED] The reply isn't

Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-10 Thread Martin Marinschek
No, we cannot include source/binary-dependencies to LGPL code - sorry. regards, Martin On 6/6/07, Cagatay Civici [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: To begin with jboss uses lgpl and that's not compatible with ASF license. Also frankly I do not want to mess with Jboss stuff cos MyFaces might face with

Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-10 Thread David Steinkopff
I read LGPLv3/GPLv3 will be compatible with Apache License 2.0. Its in that case possible to include dependencies to LGPLv3 code? regards David 2007/6/10, Martin Marinschek [EMAIL PROTECTED]: No, we cannot include source/binary-dependencies to LGPL code - sorry. regards, Martin On 6/6/07,

Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-06 Thread Andrew Robinson
The more I use JSF, the more comfortable I get with some of the 3rd party open source libraries and the strengths and weaknesses of each. Until the JSF specification catches up with the common add-on technologies for JSF, the proverbial wheel is getting re-invented all the time (PPR, skinning,

Re: Leveraging other JSF open source libraries in MyFaces with new contribution projects?

2007-06-06 Thread Mike Kienenberger
Don't know about Seam, RichFaces, or A4J, but I know that integrated support for facelets is already part of Tobago and Trinidad, and is planned for the next version of Tomahawk (for which I recently saw someone create a new branch) by leveraging the infrastructure that Trinidad provides. On