[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-29 Thread Edward Martin
Howard, I agree with everything you said, totally. That is exactly my practice with fret placement. slightly diminish the 2nd 4th frets, for renaissance tuning. Well stated! ed At 12:30 PM 3/29/2006 -0800, Howard Posner wrote: Monica Hall wrote: I have got these two CDs of baroque

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-25 Thread Martyn Hodgson
All good stuff Stewart, but does it apply to the 'baroque' guitar? As has already been pointed out, the use of 'alfabeto' moveable chord shapes impies equal temperament (or near). In particular, the M, N and H chords frequently occur in Italian printed collections using all frets

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-25 Thread EUGENE BRAIG IV
- Original Message - From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Saturday, March 25, 2006 3:38 am Subject: [LUTE] Re: Mean tone temperament sectioned frets are even necessary to get really, wholly and maybe holy ET because of the different string material and action. See this here for an

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-25 Thread Howard Posner
Jon Murphy wrote: What are distant keys? Keys that have few notes in common with the home key. A piece in C major will typically modulate to G or F or minor, but gets far afield if it drifts into A-flat or F-sharp, and in any equal temperament those sections will sound dissonant and

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-24 Thread Monica Hall
I think you should join the main lute list and ask the question there too. There have been many discussions about temperaments and (I think they're called) tastini on lutes and theorbos. Tastini is the word I was trying to think of. I'm reluctant to join the lute list as you get so many

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-23 Thread Arto Wikla
Dear Monica I don't know whether there is still anyone on this list - but if there is There are! ;-) perhaps they can tell me what they know about Mean Tone Temperament on plucked stringed instruments, especially the baroque guitar. For background you perhaps can read the following

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-23 Thread Stuart Walsh
I don't know whether there is still anyone on this list - but if there is perhaps they can tell me what they know about Mean Tone Temperament on plucked stringed instruments, especially the baroque guitar. I have got these two CDs of baroque guitar music to review. One of them says that

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-23 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 01:00 PM 3/23/2006, Monica Hall wrote: I don't know whether there is still anyone on this list - but if there is perhaps they can tell me what they know about Mean Tone Temperament on plucked stringed instruments, especially the baroque guitar... Of all places, this is receiving some

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-23 Thread Martyn Hodgson
Dear Monica, Yes, like you I wonder at it all - surely the point of moveable chord shapes (alfabeto) is that equal temp is taken as read Martyn Monica Hall [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I don't know whether there is still anyone on this list - but if there is perhaps they can

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-23 Thread Arto Wikla
Dear all, still a tiny addon to my comment on Monica's message: On Thu, 23 Mar 2006, Monica Hall wrote: As far as I'm aware the guitar was usually tuned to a sort of equal temperament - at least that is what Doisi de Velasco says and how else would they have been able to play in the 12

[VIHUELA] Re: Mean tone temperament

2006-03-23 Thread LGS-Europe
Dear Monica I play meantone temperament on my baroque guitar in continuo once in a while. I have a high first fret (f, c and b-flat) and use an extra first fret (a small tastini, actually) in a lower position for g#-sharp. E-flat or d-sharp depending on tonality high or low. It's akward,