Re: Otras tres diferencias

2005-07-10 Thread Monica Hall
: Saturday, July 09, 2005 10:05 AM Subject: Otras tres diferencias Have we a definitive understanding of what Narvaez was referring to when he entitled the piece after 'Guardame las vacas' as ''Otras tres diferencias sobre 'Guardame las vacas', hechas por otra parte''? ''Otras tres diferencias sobre

RE: Otras tres diferencias

2005-07-10 Thread Rob MacKillop
Thanks Monica. 'Guardame las vacas' is certainly based on the romanesca, but the 'Otras tres diferencias' only partially fits the passamezzo antico: i/VII/i/V/III/VII/i-V/i. 'Otras' has this chordal outline: i/VII/VI/V/i/VII/iv-V/i/iv-V/I - the first half of which is often referred to now

Re: Otras tres diferencias

2005-07-10 Thread Monica Hall
Thanks Monica. 'Guardame las vacas' is certainly based on the romanesca, but the 'Otras tres diferencias' only partially fits the passamezzo antico: i/VII/i/V/III/VII/i-V/i. 'Otras' has this chordal outline: i/VII/VI/V/i/VII/iv-V/i/iv-V/I - the first half of which is often referred to now