Re: [Vo]: Nuclear power plant scandals in Japan

2007-04-03 Thread R.C.Macaulay
Jed wrote.. Engineers are supposed to tell the truth! Howdy Jed, Good summary of the problems surrounding nuclear power. Your summary could also describe modern technology. The single greatest technological impact on society over the past 300 years is so subtle as to be unrecognized...

[Vo]: Nuclear power plant scandals in Japan

2007-04-02 Thread Jed Rothwell
In recent weeks, Japanese television and newspapers have reported that over the past 29 years there have been as many as 97 accidents and near-accidents at 12 Japanese nuclear power plants that were covered up. The most severe of these were criticality accidents that occurred when the control

Re: [Vo]: Nuclear power plant scandals in Japan

2007-04-02 Thread Jed Rothwell
Ah. The story has progressed since I last heard about it. They have now revealed 97 incidents at nuclear power plants, 128 incidents at thermal (fossil fuel) plants, and 81 at hydroelectric plants. Those power company managers have been busy little bees all these years. Here are some recent

Re: [Vo]: Nuclear power plant scandals in Japan

2007-04-02 Thread Jed Rothwell
This is astounding. The Japanese version of the Yomiuri article includes some details not translated into English, which are even worse. Japanese text here: http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/national/news/20070330it12.htm Last para, translated by me: Included in the 306 incidents listed in the report

Re: [Vo]: Nuclear power plant scandals in Japan

2007-04-02 Thread Terry Blanton
On 4/2/07, Jed Rothwell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Japan is a nation prone to cover-ups and obscurity, but this scandal takes the cake. The value of 'face' exceeds that of 'truth'. Terry

Re: [Vo]: Nuclear power plant scandals in Japan

2007-04-02 Thread Jed Rothwell
Terry Blanton writes: Japan is a nation prone to cover-ups and obscurity, but this scandal takes the cake. The value of 'face' exceeds that of 'truth'. This looks like straight out criminality to me. They did not want to turn off the reactors, pay a fine, or deal with the B.S. of regulators

Re: [Vo]: Nuclear power plant scandals in Japan

2007-04-02 Thread John Berry
The reply-to was not vortex-L@eskimo.com as I had expected, not an attempt at anonymity. Never the less I believe that the Horror of Chernobyl, reports of up to 1 Million dead and continuing impact is perhaps great enough to put Nuclear down the list a bit in terms of preferred power sources,