Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2013-02-18 Thread Ralph Giles
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 17/02/13 05:48 AM, Nils Dagsson Moskopp wrote: If one cares to that extent, and is already handling format differences, dealing with vendor variation on top isn't that much more effort. I disagree, strongly. Ok, thanks for the feedback. Do

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2013-02-17 Thread Nils Dagsson Moskopp
Ralph Giles gi...@mozilla.com schrieb am Tue, 11 Dec 2012 17:23:38 -0800: On 12-12-11 4:58 PM, Ian Hickson wrote: […] I don't think we should have an open-ended API without fixed names, because that is a recipe for an interoperability disaster. I agree it would have interoperability

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2013-01-16 Thread Ralph Giles
On 12-12-11 5:23 PM, Ralph Giles wrote: That said, I'm not convinced this is an issue given the primary use-case, which is pretty much that web content wants to do more sophisticated things with the metadata than the user-agent's standardized parsing allows. If one cares to that extent, and

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2012-12-17 Thread Robert O'Callahan
On Wed, Dec 12, 2012 at 2:23 PM, Ralph Giles gi...@mozilla.com wrote: That said, I'm not convinced this is an issue given the primary use-case, which is pretty much that web content wants to do more sophisticated things with the metadata than the user-agent's standardized parsing allows. If

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2012-12-11 Thread Ian Hickson
On Thu, 20 Sep 2012, Ralph Giles wrote: Back in June, I proposed[1] a new attribute to get metadata tag data out of media resources. I've done an experimental implementation of this which is now in the Firefox Aurora (alpha) channel[2] and Nightly development builds. The method is

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2012-12-11 Thread Ralph Giles
On 12-12-11 4:58 PM, Ian Hickson wrote: This seems reasonable. Thanks for the feedback. Anyone else? :-) I don't want to be the one to maintain the mapping from media formats to metadata schema, because this isn't my area of expertise, and it isn't trivial work. Good point. This would

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2012-11-27 Thread Ralph Giles
On 12-11-26 4:18 PM, Ralph Giles wrote: interface HTMLMediaElement { ... object getMetadata(); }; After the metadataloaded event fires, this method would return a new object containing a copy of the metadata read from the resource, in whatever format the decoder implementation

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2012-11-26 Thread Ralph Giles
On 12-09-27 1:44 AM, Philip Jägenstedt wrote: I'm skeptical that all that we want from ID3v2 or common VorbisComment tags can be mapped to Dublin Core, it seems better to define mappings directly from the underlying format to the WebIDL interface. You're right. Given the open-endedness of

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2012-09-27 Thread Philip Jägenstedt
On Fri, 21 Sep 2012 01:32:19 +0200, Ralph Giles gi...@mozilla.com wrote: Back in June, I proposed[1] a new attribute to get metadata tag data out of media resources. I've done an experimental implementation of this which is now in the Firefox Aurora (alpha) channel[2] and Nightly development

[whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2012-06-11 Thread Ralph Giles
Recently, we've been considering adding a 'tags' or 'metadata' attribute to HTML media elements in Firefox, to allow webcontent access to metadata from the playing media resource. In particular we're interested in tag data like creator, title, date, and so on. My recollection is that this has

Re: [whatwg] metadata attribute for media

2012-06-11 Thread Silvia Pfeiffer
On Tue, Jun 12, 2012 at 7:53 AM, Ralph Giles gi...@mozilla.com wrote: Recently, we've been considering adding a 'tags' or 'metadata' attribute to HTML media elements in Firefox, to allow webcontent access to metadata from the playing media resource. In particular we're interested in tag data