Re: [whatwg] Feedback on the ping= attribute (ISSUE-1)

2007-11-03 Thread Krzysztof Żelechowski
Dnia 02-11-2007, pią o godzinie 22:05 +, Ian Hickson napisał(a): On Sun, 28 Oct 2007, Roy T. Fielding wrote: Aside from all of the other issues, my vote would be to remove the ping attribute from the specification. It is not a desirable feature. [snip] It is not sufficient for

Re: [whatwg] Feedback on the ping= attribute (ISSUE-1)

2007-11-03 Thread Dan Connolly
Julian Reschke wrote: [...] On Sat, 27 Oct 2007, Julian Reschke wrote: We're long past that. It's trivial for a page to trigger a POST without the user knowing. I consider that a bug in User Agents. This is not a widely held opinion. Well, it's what RFC2616 says. I would argue that if the

[whatwg] Feedback on the ping= attribute (ISSUE-1)

2007-11-02 Thread Ian Hickson
This e-mail contains replies to a number of e-mails received on the topic of the proposed ping= attribute since January 2006. Since e-mail on this topic was sent to both the WHATWG and HTMLWG mailing lists, I have cc'ed both on this e-mail. Please pick just one when replying. Thanks! On Thu, 19

Re: [whatwg] Feedback on the ping= attribute (ISSUE-1)

2007-11-02 Thread Boris Zbarsky
Ian Hickson wrote: I agree that ping= should be made visible to users. Indeed, the spec explicitly makes that a SHOULD, going far outside its usual boundary of not specifying user interface requirements. For what it's worth, this thread sparked some discussion at