Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-03-01 Thread Thomas Wootten
On 26/02/2010 16:54, wpkg-users-requ...@lists.wpkg.org wrote: -- Message: 3 Date: Fri, 26 Feb 2010 22:00:39 +1000 From: Peter Goughpmgo...@gmail.com To: Chris Wilcoxnot_rich_...@hotmail.com Cc: wpkgwpkg-users@lists.wpkg.org Subject: Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-03-01 Thread Bill Prentice
If the software has something that can be checked install checks are written properly you can have a minimum version or something similar. In my environment I want specific versions installed so as to be able to properly support my environment so I specify exact version information as much as

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-03-01 Thread Rainer Meier
Hi Tomas, Someone did mention a /noremove switch though. I presume this makes WPKG not remove stuff, ever. Since I'm unlikely to want to remove stuff using wpkg, how can I use this switch or an equivalent configuration option? I do not recommend to use this switch in production. Mainly due to

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-27 Thread Rainer Meier
Hi Peter, Simply put if for some reason I decide to rollout Firefox v3.5 to all of my clients but some of my users have already installed v3.6 then wpkg may install the older version over the top of the newer version assuming I use a check condition that specifies the file version as v3.5..

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-27 Thread Peter Gough
Yes, all true and well worth clarification. I only offer my advice based on my own experience which is that without careful testing it is difficult to predict exactly what the implementation of wpkg will have. I've certainly tripped up more than once as a result of my own ill-conceived check

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-27 Thread Rainer Meier
Hi Peter, On 27.02.2010 13:07, Peter Gough wrote: I only offer my advice based on my own experience which is that without careful testing it is difficult to predict exactly what the implementation of wpkg will have. I've certainly tripped up more than once as a result of my own ill-conceived

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-26 Thread Chris Wilcox
Date: Fri, 26 Feb 2010 11:33:20 + From: jetsho...@o2.co.uk To: wpkg-users@lists.wpkg.org Subject: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install? Will wpkg uninstall software it did not install, if said software is installed on the computer, has an entry in

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-26 Thread Peter Gough
My experience is that this is *mostly* true. For example if you decide to roll out v1 of a package but a user has already manually installed v2 and your check only looks for v1 files then you could potentially have a situation where wpkg tries to install the older version on top of the newer

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-26 Thread Pendl Stefan
Will wpkg uninstall software it did not install, if said software is installed on the computer, has an entry in packages.xml, but is not in the relevant profile? The desired behaviour for myself is that wpkg _not_ do that. Since users are allowed to install their own software if they

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-26 Thread Kevin Keane
-Original Message- Will wpkg uninstall software it did not install, if said software is installed on the computer, has an entry in packages.xml, but is not in the relevant profile? The desired behaviour for myself is that wpkg _not_ do that. Since users are allowed to

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-26 Thread Rainer Meier
Hi Kevin, On 26.02.2010 23:19, Kevin Keane wrote: WPKG does __not__ scan the installed software and remove anything, which does not match the profile of the computer. To be honest, I don't completely trust WPKG in this respect. I have never been able to conclusively determine any scenario,

Re: [wpkg-users] Will WPKG uninstall software it did not install?

2010-02-26 Thread Peter Gough
Agreed but this isn't the scenario I was describing. Simply put if for some reason I decide to rollout Firefox v3.5 to all of my clients but some of my users have already installed v3.6 then wpkg may install the older version over the top of the newer version assuming I use a check condition that