Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-24 Thread Stephen Stagg
you're right of course. I should use an OL and put the breadcrumb text as a heading. However I found this method to be the most compliant and easiest to implement, and it is understandable in most browsers. On 23 Feb 2006, at 20:55, Patrick H. Lauke wrote: Stephen Stagg wrote: For

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-23 Thread Ian Anderson
Kevin Futter wrote: Anyway, for the benefit of others interested in this thread/topic, the upshot from the above link seems to be that the pipe character (|) is the best compromise currently available as a screen reader-friendly element separator. I profoundly disagree with that. The vertical

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-23 Thread Stephen Stagg
On 23 Feb 2006, at 11:19, Ian Anderson wrote: Kevin Futter wrote: Anyway, for the benefit of others interested in this thread/topic, the upshot from the above link seems to be that the pipe character (|) is the best compromise currently available as a screen reader-friendly element

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-23 Thread Jon Gunderson
2006 11:19:45 + From: Ian Anderson [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1 To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Kevin Futter wrote: Anyway, for the benefit of others interested in this thread/topic, the upshot from the above link seems to be that the pipe character

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-23 Thread Ian Anderson
Ian Anderson wrote: http://www.standards-schmandards.com/?2004/11/06/6-the-sound-of-the-accessibl e-title-tag-separator Anyway, for the benefit of others interested in this thread/topic, the upshot from the above link seems to be that the pipe character (|) is the best compromise currently

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-23 Thread Patrick H. Lauke
Stephen Stagg wrote: For the benefit of Screen-readers and textmode browsers, I add a LI with the text 'breadcrumb' at the top of the list which is then hidden using CSS. It's not a perfect solution but it works. ul li class=firstBreadcrumb: / liaMenu Item 1// liaMenu Item 2//

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-23 Thread Kevin Futter
On 23/2/06 10:19 PM, Ian Anderson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Kevin Futter wrote: Anyway, for the benefit of others interested in this thread/topic, the upshot from the above link seems to be that the pipe character (|) is the best compromise currently available as a screen reader-friendly

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-22 Thread Kevin Futter
On 22/2/06 10:38 AM, Patrick H. Lauke [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Kevin Futter wrote: My only concern about using a string of text is defining a semantically-appropriate item delimiter that works well for assistive technologies. This seems apropos:

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-21 Thread Patrick H. Lauke
Kevin Futter wrote: Yes, I've argued strongly in the past that a list is not completely semantically-appropriate for breadcrumbs markup. Unlike breadcrumbs, a flat list does not represent a hierarchy, unless you nest them ... Of course I have to qualify this by saying that I treat breadcrumbs

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-21 Thread Kevin Futter
On 21/2/06 7:00 PM, Patrick H. Lauke [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Kevin Futter wrote: Yes, I've argued strongly in the past that a list is not completely semantically-appropriate for breadcrumbs markup. Unlike breadcrumbs, a flat list does not represent a hierarchy, unless you nest them ...

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-21 Thread Patrick H. Lauke
Kevin Futter wrote: While I can concede that an ordered list offers more chance of an implied hierarchy than an unordered one, I'm not keen on the amount of code required to produce the result, nor the concept of a series of nested lists, each with one element. I'm not keen on the nesting of

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-21 Thread Marilyn Langfeld
I thought it would be interesting to see what Yahoo says (and does) about breadcrumbs in their pattern library: http:// developer.yahoo.net/ypatterns/pattern_breadcrumbs.php They don't discuss the HTML, but looking at the source, I see they use an unordered list in some sort of template, as

[WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-20 Thread James Hunter
Hi All, I'm working on site with a large amount of content that can get up to 5 levels deep. With a breadcrumb such as: My Site Developers Resources Specific Resource I've been reading this: http://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG10-HTML-TECHS/#document-headers Specifically I would like some

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-20 Thread russ - maxdesign
I want to use the name of the site in the H1. Is it appropriate to use the breadcrumb as the H1 element? I'd say it is better to use the h1 element for the site name as an initial statement then use something like an ordered list or unordered list for the breadcrumb: h1 Site name /h1 ol

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-20 Thread Doc
James,I'd suggest this guideline refers to the body content of a page rather than navigational elements. If it were me, I wouldn't wrap an H1 around the breadcrumbs (or part thereof). I would reserve the use of H1, H2 etc for page headings, section headings, bylines, sub-section titles etc only.

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-20 Thread James Hunter
Thanks Russ, and Steve thats 2 no's I don't need any more convincing. I'll leave the site name as the first heading. Cheers, James -- James Hunter ** The discussion list for http://webstandardsgroup.org/ See

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-20 Thread Terrence Wood
James Hunter: Is it appropriate to use the breadcrumb as the H1 element? Breadcrumbs do not describe the *document* structure - they hint at the *site* structure (provided you only provide a hierarchal navigation system) or site history (depending on what type of breadcrumb you employ).

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-20 Thread Jay Gilmore
Terrence Wood wrote: James Hunter: Is it appropriate to use the breadcrumb as the H1 element? I'm thinking out aloud here: not sure why, but using a list for breadcrumbs doesn't quite sit right with me, despite it being a type of navigation device. I think it is due to list structures

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-20 Thread Seona Bellamy
On 21/02/06, Terrence Wood [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm thinking out aloud here: not sure why, but using a list forbreadcrumbs doesn't quite sit right with me, despite it being a type ofnavigation device. I think it is due to list structures replacing thedir and menu elements - and the notion that

Re: [WSG] Breadcrumb as Section Heading H1

2006-02-20 Thread Kevin Futter
On 21/2/06 12:31 PM, Terrence Wood [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: James Hunter: Is it appropriate to use the breadcrumb as the H1 element? Breadcrumbs do not describe the *document* structure - they hint at the *site* structure (provided you only provide a hierarchal navigation system) or site