[Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-22 Thread anatmanwave
---Ah, better question. Yes you can practice Zen without offically becoming a Buddhist. but I wouldn't get so stuck on the semantics. I am a budhist, I'm not a Buddhist; eh, makes no difference to the path. Guy In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Bill Smart [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Mike and Guy,

Re: [Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-22 Thread Al
From: anatmanwave Yes you can practice Zen without offically becoming a Buddhist. Don't forget to send me your $5 donation for the I AM A BUDDHIST membership card. Current Book Discussion: any Zen book that you recently have read or are reading! Talk about it today! Yahoo! Groups Links *

Re: [Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-22 Thread mike brown
Or maybe the raft fee is $5? Al [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: anatmanwave Yes you can practice Zen without offically becoming a Buddhist. Don't forget to send me your $5 donation for the I AM A BUDDHIST membership card.

Re: [Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-22 Thread mike brown
Let me amend that - a raft disposal collection fee. Al [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: anatmanwave Yes you can practice Zen without offically becoming a Buddhist. Don't forget to send me your $5 donation for the I AM A BUDDHIST membership card.

Re: [Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-21 Thread mike brown
The heart of the subject is the same. anatmanwave [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ---Same thing, Zen comes from Chan from the Chinese, they morphed it from India. Just a matter of semantics but subject is the same. Guy In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Bill Smart [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What

[Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-21 Thread Bill Smart
Mike and Guy, Thank you for your responses. Let me ask this question a different way: Can you practice zen without being buddhist? If no, why? If not, why? Thanks...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, mike brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The heart of the subject is the same.

[Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-21 Thread Bill Smart
Ooops! That was not a TRICK question. I meant to ask: Can you practice zen without being buddhist? If NO, why? If YES, why? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Bill Smart [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Mike and Guy, Thank you for your responses. Let me ask this question a

Re: [Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-21 Thread daniel sherwood
I think one can practice Zen without being a Buddhist because Zen is a philosophy and not a religion. All one has to do is sit... - Original Message From: Bill Smart [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Sent: Friday, December 21, 2007 9:31:26 PM Subject: [Zen] Re: Not Caveat

Re: [Zen] Re: Not Caveat Emptor

2007-12-21 Thread mike brown
Hi Bill! (nice to see they let you out on weekends) It's still a trick question of sorts (whether intentional or not) because ultimately it will lead to a pardox (zen and buddhism are the same, but not). In that sense, I believe zen is different because zen goes beyond the question and