First off, let me say that I love Trac. It's been a huge help to my development group. However, I'm not sure I would want to make the argument of Trac over Roundup. I've been a big fan of Roundup since way back, and I would love to see it get the kind of momentum that you mention Trac having. Roundup has always had some great ideas and I think it has some powerful features that would be really useful for OSS development.
I think Roundup's strongest points are: --email notification, especially the nosy list I find that Trac's email notification never works quite the way I want it to. Either I turn on the "always_notify_x" switches and get too many emails or I turn it off and get too few. Roundup's nosy list concept is simple, intuitive, and very powerful. I'd love to see it implemented in Trac. --generic object model Roundup's flexibility in creating new object types with states and interlinking is very nice. I've seen the Trac Object Model Proposal and it looks like an attempt to implement a similar idea for Trac, which would be great. http://projects.edgewall.com/trac/wiki/TracObjectModelProposal --Easy setup While this wouldn't be an issue in this instance, Roundup is no problem to install and get running while Trac can be an absolute nightmare with all of its dependencies. Trac's strongest points in comparison to Roundup are: --Much more polished look-and-feel It looks and works great out of the box (assuming you can actually get all its dependencies installed). --Tight integration (subversion, wiki, ticketing) --Clean plugin model for extension I think that both are very well designed, but I'd love to see Roundup get the kind of attention that Trac has gotten and see where Roundup goes. Alex Buccino Chris Ryland <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent by: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 03/28/2006 12:43 PM Please respond to trac To: trac@lists.edgewall.com cc: Subject: [Trac] sell Guido on Trac I'm (privately, via email) trying to sell Guido (Python BDFL) on the use of Trac vs. Roundup for future Python development (e.g., Python 3000). How would I make the case to him? The main advantage I would see in Trac is it's excellent Subversion integration, which is not really built-in to RoundUp, plus Trac's much greater momentum in the OSS worlds. Cheers! --Chris Ryland / Em Software, Inc. / www.emsoftware.com _______________________________________________ Trac mailing list Trac@lists.edgewall.com http://lists.edgewall.com/mailman/listinfo/trac _______________________________________________ Trac mailing list Trac@lists.edgewall.com http://lists.edgewall.com/mailman/listinfo/trac
