I am just stating a fact, not judging the validity of anybody's claims.There would be no airplanes today if the Wright brothers hadn't allowed skeptics to judge their claims with their own instruments (=own eyes in their case). Luckily, they were not that stupid.
Michel 2010/3/26 Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com>: > Michel Jullian wrote: > >> Duncan didn't bring in his own measurement system so he didn't see the >> excess heat for himself. > > Oh give me a break. > > That's ridiculous. The technique was replicated as SRI and ENEA. CBS sent > one of the world top experts in calorimetry to confirm it. What more do you > want? Do you seriously think that Scott Little with his MOAC would provide > better confirmation than this? > > Are you suggesting that Duncan can't recognize when an instrument is > malfunctioning? Or that they might have fooled him with fake instruments? > That is like suggesting that you could fool me into thinking someone is > speaking Japanese when they are speaking gibberish. I can tell. It is my > second language. Rob Duncan speaks calorimetry the way Edward Seidensticker > spoke Japanese. > > You come up with such improbable reasons to disbelieve these results! You > are grasping at straws, the way Dieter Britz does. One day you imagine that > Rossi has somehow crammed $60 million of plutonium into his cell, and the > next you tell us that the world's top expert in calorimetry may be so > incompetent he doesn't know amps from volts. How else can someone mistake > 0.8 W for 20 W? > > - Jed > >
