Hi,
On 10-8-2011 23:37, Jed Rothwell wrote:
Alan J Fletcher wrote:
I meant that Rossi could have taken a core to Defkalion for internal
tests in a Hyperion rig -- NOT the government tests -- but not left
it with them.
This would allow the following two statements to be true:
R: Nobody has an eCat
D: We measured 6-20x energy gain
That simply cannot be reconciled with Defkalion's statements. They
clearly, repeatedly said they are getting excess heat, and they
delivered systems to the Greek government. Therefore they must have
eCats, and Rossi either delivered a bunch of cores to them
permanently, or they manufactured the cores themselves. Assuming they
are telling the truth, there is no chance that Rossi brought some
cores over, stood by, and then brought them back.
Defkalion's response in PESN says clearly that they have working
reactors:
"Defkalion Green Technologies has designed, built and tested the
materials and components for the final Hyperion products that are
based on the same kernels (reactors) as of Andrea Rossi's e-cats.
Their official testing, certification and approval by the Greek
Authorities is still in progress."
No, I think the wrong questions are put forward.
Rossi says: Nobody has eCat.
As an engineer myself this can be very well true, as an eCat is in my
perception the full device with all inlet/outlet pipes made by Rossi
with possibly a very small replaceable closed
core/container/cartridge/vessel/module with the catalyzer inside it,
which cannot be opened.
This would allow for easy refill at site with a new module, without the
need to take the full device out of service for to long and bring it to
the factory.
I wouldn't be surprised if this was one of Defkalions requirements to Rossi.
This maybe one of the main reasons we don't know how the full eCat
reactor looks like inside.
Remember version 4 at Danielle's Blog of May 15th, 2011?
But has anyone asked him if Defkalion has the inner module part with the
catalyzer in it?
If they have several moduleS, then the only thing they need to do is
design+engineer+manufacture+integrate+test their own hyperionS with the
moduleS provided by Rossi. In that case both are telling the full truth.
Kind regards,
MoB
