Hi Carles, My thought is inline;
>[....] > > 3a "Routing requirements" (which needs its own milestone entry) has a > > draft from Dominik Kaspar, Eunsook Kim, and Carsten Bormann. During > > the RL2N BOF, a similar document was proposed as a result of the > > RL2N-followup WG to be formed. We need to understand whether the two > > documents (the 6lowpan one and the rl2n++ one) are sufficiently > > different or whether we simply need to cooperate on one document, > > which would then have to include the 6lowpan-specific aspects > > including mesh-under. > > We believe, at least at this time, it might not be necessary having two > different routing requirements documents (one from RL2N and one from > 6LoWPAN). Since LoWPAN scenarios are a subset of those considered by RL2N, > at least there should be an RL2N requirements document, which should > address the requirements for 6LoWPAN. If RL2N requirements were too broad > for 6LoWPAN, then a routing requirements document for 6LoWPAN would make > sense. > [E] Carles, as you already know, RL2N focuses on 3 scenarios at this moment based on multiple PHY/MAC condition. I believe that 6LoWPAN needs its own routing requirement narrowing down the scope of the document as 6LoWPAN specific, including its very unique node characteristics. I think that RL2N can use the input as one of the area where RL2N solution will be used. > > 4 "Use Cases for 6LoWPAN". Zach Shelby has indicated his interest. > > Eunsook Kim et al.'s "Design and Application Spaces for 6LoWPANs" > > might provide a basis, but we need more input, in particular from > > implementors of each of these scenarios that we actually want to use > > as use cases. > > We can contribute. We have developed applications for home automation, > healthcare and city management environments. > [E] I think the current "application space" documents contains home automation and healthcare. I think the doc need to have deeper depth by collecting experiences like you did. It must be great to work together. -eunah _______________________________________________ 6lowpan mailing list [email protected] https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/6lowpan
