Hello, Geoff and all - comments inline. Geoff Mulligan wrote:
Carsten and I don't want to interrupt this discussion, but we would like to remind everyone that we also have one CRITICAL short term objective: Getting rechartered.
I feel that the proposed charter is nicely structured with well defined scope and support it with minimal changes.
The *theme of the week* for the working group is the finalization of the charter. In particular, the following questions have been raised: A) is the timeline, which was too tight, now too relaxed? (Obviously, the chairs don't think so, but what do you think?)
From my standpoint of view the timeline _could_ be even more aggressive on some items but maybe it's best to keep it as it is in order to remain realistic.
B) should there be work on a "minimal 6lowpan/IPv6 profile"? (We had envisioned each of the use cases to explain what protocols are used in implementing that particular use case, not the generation of a unified minimal profile that would apply to all use cases.)
I think this would be recommendable as there seems to be several issues that need to be defined in order to guarantee system level interoperability. I would also be willing to contribute to this item.
Eunah has already mentioned on the list about the informal meeting that some of us (Eunah, JP, Dominik, Jonathan and I) had in Vancouver on the possible minimal 6lowpan profile item. I took some notes on the meeting and will probably post them later on the list.
> F) Going through each of the documents, the following contributions
have been promised recently: 1 "6LoWPAN Bootstrapping and 6LoWPAN IPv6 ND Optimizations": We have longstanding contributions from Samita Chakrabarti and Erik Nordmark. Anybody else? Daniel has also proposed to split 1 into bootstrapping and ND optimization. There is also the subject of commissioning. What is the right set of documents, and which ones do (each of) you want to work on?
I would be willing to contribute to this item.
7 Interop guide: Zach Shelby and Jonathan Hui are interested. What about the other folks that have built or are building 6LoWPAN implementations.
Best regards, -- Mr. Mikko Saarnivala | Software systems | +358 50 5696287 Sensinode Ltd. | <URL:http://www.sensinode.com> _______________________________________________ 6lowpan mailing list [email protected] https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/6lowpan
