> RAID has some disadvantages, eg. you have to nail-down partition
> sizes and it's not trivial to resize or move around volumes.

you seem to be making a general claim about all storage
management solutions that i don't think can be backed
up.

as an example i have no rooting interest in, way back
in 1996, i was able to use aix lvm to migrate a couple
of hundred filesystems in many tens of vgs to tens of
filesystems on a handful of vgs with mirrored lvs.  i
didn't find it hard at all to reallocate or resize
anything.  there were no partitions in sight.

(i sure don't miss dasd.)

> A venti-based system (which maybe presents an block device via
> venti) can make runtime configuration much easier.

combining functionality that is logically distinct is
generally called unmodular, and a layering violation
in this particular senerio.

- erik


Reply via email to