Phil Katz wrote:

 >Imo the Danish tune does not begin to be Jenny Lind (except
 >under that convention that any two tunes in the same key(s) with
 >roughly the same phrasing and 1-2 similar runs are the same
 >tune.)

You need to learn to see the forest through the trees. Measures
2, 3, and 4 (and therefore measure 6 as well) have nearly the
same outline in both tunes, and more importantly, they *sound*
similar. The A sections are as similar as any two versions of
"Soldier's Joy." 

  ______      /\/\/\/\
 <______>     | | | | |  David Barnert
 <______>     | | | | |  <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
 <______>     | | | | |  Albany, N.Y.
 <______>     \/\/\/\/

Ventilator   Concertina
  Bellows      Bellows
(Vocation)   (Avocation)

To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html

Reply via email to