Buddha Buck <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> At 07:39 PM 04-18-2002 +0000, John Chambers you wrote:
> >I've also been contemplating solving the need for random text such as
> >"last time" under an ending bracket. This obviously needs quotes, and
> >has syntax problems after a bar line.  What I think would work is  to
> >say that you must use the '[' in this case, and you can then write
> >    |: CEC DED |1-3 EGE FAF :|2,4 EFG FED :|["last time" EFG ABc :|
> 
> I'm one of the people that feels that ABC should be able to be used to
> unambiguously describe a piece of music without the need for human
> intelligence to interpret it.  As such, for the case of "last repeat has
> a special variant", I don't think an arbitrary text string method is the
> right solution (it may be right for other things, but not for
> information on how to play the music).
> 
> I would suggest that there be a special code used for things like that,
> such as a repeat-number beginning with '0x', (like 0xlast, 0xfirst, etc)
> that could be used to indicate alternate endings under special cases. 
> Done right, it could be extensible to newer repeat patterns as needed in
> the future.

I agree - keep the flow control characters mandatory and add a 
separate 'funky text' mechanism.

cheers,
e.
To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html

Reply via email to