> In piobaireachd, a section which plays 
>   | AA | AA | BB | AA | BB | BB | AA | BB ||
> is generally put on the page as
>   |:: ["twice first time" AA] | ["twice second time" BB] ::|
> i.e.
>   |:: [1x2,2,3 AA] | [1,2x2,3 BB] ::|

I don't understand how either the second or third represent the first.

Isn't this kind of repeat exactly what ABC's "P:" construct is good at?

Write your structure like this:

[header]
   P:XXYX YYXY

[body]
   P:X
   |:A:|
   P:Y
   |:B:|

I posted an example here a while back ("Weighing from Land") using the
P: construct that way, along with BarFly macros to get it shorter, and
I represented the entire content of the Kilberry (I think) edition except
for the variable-length gracenotes; the ABC in the tune body was pretty
much symbol-for-symbol isomorphic with standard piobaireachd notation.

Obviously I picked a nicely regular example, but, while there may be
essential uses for the extra notation you're suggesting, I don't think
piobaireachd is one of them.

=================== <http://www.purr.demon.co.uk/jack/> ===================


To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html

Reply via email to