Hi, > All I asked was a possible collaboration, I feel very > disappointed that my offer is prematurely rejected. I think > excluding me from collaboration is a very unfriendly gesture. > I have not offended anyone here before.
Indeed, I am interested in collaborating with you and others on an AGI consortium, and I don't think I said I wasn't. In fact, what I said was that I thought it made some sense to turn AGIRI into an AGI R&D consortium by moving the Novamente-specific stuff currently on the AGIRI site to the Novamente.net website. Once I make these website changes (which I'll do when I get the time, hopefully within the next week) then we can collaborate on the new improved AGIRI-as-AGI-consortium website revision, if you wish to do s. > Ben: I asked you if you have a concern with capturing > AGI market value / establishing market dominance. And > your response was flickering. That's very bad in terms > of trust building. Of course, I have an interest in making money with AI and AGI. My own current plan is to make money using narrow-AI systems constructed using fragments of my in-development AGI system. I am neutral presently as to whether it will make sense to do the latter stages of Novamente AGI development in a commercial or purely research setting. This depends on a lot of things that are currently unknown. > If you're not interested in money, and if you're *mainly* > interested in research, I think we can still collaborate. In > fact, that'll even be easier to collaborate. As a human being, I am primarily interested in research. However, I am currently also very interested in making money, as a subgoal of my interest in research. Money is useful for funding research (among other purposes!). I don't think one needs to become as big as Microsoft or IBM to fund AGI research very amply, however. I think AGI is best done by a small, tightly focused team, with ongoing feedback from a larger group of loosely affiliated scientists. If I had enough research funding to pay for, say 10-15 full-time AGI scientists/engineers to work on *nothing but AGI*, then I'd consider this adequate to bring us to AGI. Having a lot of people and a lot of money brings its own problems, including a lot of bureaucratic and managerial overhead. I don't now have enough funding to pay for such an AGI R&D team, and I hope to generate this money through my AI business ventures. But in the context of the US business world this requires a relatively modest amount of money, not M$-style market domination. For example, a $1 million annual budget for Novamente AGI research would be more than adequate. So anyway, it's not that I don't have an interest in money. It's that I think I have a realistic assessment of how much money is required for a maximally productive AGI team. Beyond a certain size, adding people to an AGI project will diminish rather than increase productivity. And, history shows that big companies are not that good at getting highly innovative research done. Even Microsoft, with its culture of intelligence and productivity, hasn't really gotten that much out of its investment in Microsoft Research. Useful stuff, but nothing mindblowing ... Whereas the world outside M$ has certainly conceived a lot of wild and interesting things over the same time-period that M$ Research has existed... Finally, I see the role of an AGI Consortium as being -- the promotion of AGI R&D -- the development of tools generally useful for AGI development -- the pursuit of AGI-oriented or closely related research not specifically tied to one or another AGI software system As I said before I don't think an AGI Consortium should be thought of as a profit-making enterprise... -- Ben G ------- To unsubscribe, change your address, or temporarily deactivate your subscription, please go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/[EMAIL PROTECTED]
