On Sun, 2021-08-29 at 00:10 +1000, Telna via agora-official wrote: > Having been entered into Moot, I hereby initiate the Agoran Decision > to determine public confidence in R. Lee's judgement of CFJ 3922. > > For this decision, the vote collector is the Arbitor, the voting > method is first-past-the-post, and the valid options and their > consequences are listed below. (PRESENT is also a valid vote, as are > conditional votes) > * AFFIRM - uphold R. Lee's judgement as final > * REMAND - reopen the case for reconsideration by R. Lee > * REMIT - reopen the case, recusing and barring R. Lee > The quorum for this decision is 6. Please note that a result of > FAILED QUORUM is treated identically to AFFIRM.
I vote REMAND. I think the judgement mostly makes sense, but the "to be adopted according to the current rule adoption procedure" doesn't make much sense in a proposal and the judgement hasn't taken this into account – this is a point that should have been addressed. -- ais523
