n.b. also contains partial suggested revision of Scope proposal

I vote as follows:

8607*   Telna, ais523, Alexis   3.0   Asset Self-Ratification Fix
FOR
8608*   Telna, Jason, G., [1]   3.0   Powering Up
AGAINST
8609&   Jason                   1.0   Axiom of Limitations
FOR
8610&   Jason                   1.7   No Immediate Shenanigans
FOR
8611&   Jason, Trigon           1.0   Reasonably Responsive Reactivation
AGAINST
8612&   Jason, G., Ørjan        1.0   Tournament Conclusion Fixes v2
PRESENT
8613*   Jason, Trigon           3.0   The Name of the Win Cards v2
PRESENT
8614*   Jason                   3.0   Simultaneity Security
FOR
8615*   Jason                   3.0   Supporter/Objector clarification v2
PRESENT
8616&   nix, Telna, Trigon      1.0   Narrowing Margins
PRESENT
8617&   nix, G.                 1.0   Forgiveness
PRESENT
8618&   nix, Jason              1.0   Solo Acitivity
FOR
8619&   ATMunn                  1.0   The Bottomless Pit
FOR
8620&   R. Lee                  1.0   Im coolxa
FOR
8621*   R. Lee                  3.0   Proposal spreading
FOR
8622*   R. Lee                  3.0   [2]
PRESENT
8623&   Trigon                  1.0   No prizeless victory auctions
FOR
8624&   Trigon                  1.0   I'd like to thank the academy
FOR
8625&   Trigon                  1.0   giving the gift of an amendment
PRESENT
8626*   Trigon, Jason, ais523   3.0   pledge(2)(2)

AGAINST

Suggested fix:

  * When a player states that e takes an action within a scope, then
    rules to the contrary notwithstanding, that action fails if any of
    the following is true:

      a) The scope specifies that it allows one or more types of
         actions (unblocked actions), and the action is not unblocked.

      b) The scope specifies that it prevents one or more types of
         actions (blocked actions), and the action is blocked.

  * If it would otherwise be unclear or ambiguous whether an action
    would fail due to its scope, then its scope is the null scope.

  * The following scopes are defined:

      - Null scope: All actions are blocked.
      - Global scope: All actions are unblocked.
      (etc.)

8627&   G.                      1.0   INSANITY CLAUSES
AGAINST
8628&   G.                      2.0   tacking into the win
PRESENT
8629*   G., Telna, nix, [3]     3.0   Independence Day
PRESENT

Reply via email to