On Wed, Jun 18, 2008 at 7:01 AM, Geoffrey Spear <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>> ==============================  CFJ 2013  ==============================>
>>    Rule 2141 implies that a rule can destroy the universe.
>
> I rule FALSE.  Rule 2141 implies that the rules may allow or disallow
> the destruction of the universe (although in the latter case it would
> be rather difficult to pursue a criminal case against a violator), but
> even though their scope is unlimited by Rule 2141 they are still
> rules, or "regulation[s] determining the methods or course of a game
> or the like" (OED), and as such lack the capacity and do not claim to
> have the capacity to affect the world outside of the game except by
> prescribing or proscribing certain behavior by entities the rules
> claim to govern.

"Rule" is defined by R2141, so the appeal to common definition is incorrect.

-root

Reply via email to