On 10/26/25 6:22 PM, Cosmo via agora-business wrote:
Note that, under R1607, only distributed proposals have ID numbers.
Honestly not sure how I didn't notice the fact that I seem to have forgotten
that when I wrote my automation, thanks for pointing it out.
I CFJ: "The promotor MAY assign IDs to proposals that have not been
distributed."
Arguments for TRUE:
Nowhere in the rules does it prohibit giving proposals in the pool IDs (as
far as I can tell).
Arguments for FALSE:
R1607, 5th paragraph ("Distibuted proposals have...")
[Either way I'll change my report a bit, how exactly will probably depend on
the ruling of this CFJ]
Argument against the practice (even if the CFJ rules in its favor): a
withdrawn proposal leaves a hole in the numbering
--
Mischief
Collar, Collector, Prime Minister
Hat: steampunk hat
