Some of the things that are really perplexing: 1) Why do all the accessibilty/humanitarian apps have such a low score on originality. There are very few handsets if any that have these features. 2) The target demographic of the disabled deaf/blind/cognitive/etc. is a totally untapped market, as explained in 1) . So wouldn't it be smarter to address an untapped demographic, than to compete against existing handset players where there is cut-throat competition?
On May 18, 10:05 pm, gtandon <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > hmmmm....from the list here (and I am sure there must've been more), I > would have traded one of these in lieu of one of the 3 weather apps, > or one of the quite a few social networking apps doing the same thing, > then there was the WriterPad thing where you move your pen on the > letters to form words, quite a few family safety apps that seems to be > doing useful work which could easily be doled out to 911, etc, etc... > > So I don't buy it that there weren't enough apps to choose from, or > that there were "more original" apps from the ones that were ranked > higher up. Agreed, none of these would be either "popular" or > "profitable" due to the marginal demographics that they support, but > that is the nature of these type of applications. And Google should > have been careful about including these categories for possible > entries to the challenge. > > My application is called SmallWorld, and it is meant to connect kids > from developed nations with under priviledged kids all over the world. > It is a kid-to-kid type of an application, where children would accrue > reward points to find sponsors, make friends and keep connected with > their under priviledged friends. The concept is that instead of just > supporting them with money, kids from developed countries could also > stay in touch (phone to PC). And what better way to have them than use > their phone to do this, where they are always connected and can > recieve reminders (thanks to Android notifications). > > The application has a widget engine which allows kids to build mobile > notes (with text, pictures or voice) and send it to a PC or phone > (XMPP to another phone user). The application currently allows 6 > different templates(including language templates) to choose from, > finish with their content and sending to their counter parts. When > Android starts supporting dynamic loading of layouts, a way for > content providers to offer mobile content thru infinite templates, for > kids to pick up and customize their content. > > The application would fall under humanitarian (while these kids are > helping other kids, they are also growing up with a much better > understanding of the world than just Nick and Disney and facebook) as > well something that will facilitate economic development (for example > kids can generate sponsorship amounts toward's their friend's > education, and education is the core of any economic development). And > while doing all this the kids could be collecting reward points... > > Agreed not as good as some other apps here from the perspective of > immediate value. > > This was my rank > > Effective use: In the 50th to 75th percentile of all submitted > applications > Polish: In the 50th to 75th percentile of all submitted applications > Indispensability: In the lower 25% of all submitted applications > Originality: In the lower 25% of all submitted applications > > Overall: In the lower 25% of all submitted applications > > On May 17, 1:27 pm, "Dan U." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > > > There is no > > > application from this category (except if we consider the family > > > safety type of apps) in the first 50. > > > I don't know why no humanitarian apps were chosen, but I could form a > > guess. First, I recall shortly before the submission deadline, someone > > in the group asked for more humanitarian app submissions. This person > > had a google.com email, so it might have been a Google employee. I > > don't really know. If so, it sounds like they hadn't gotten many > > submissions for that category. Because of that, it seems like there > > were few to choose from and the judges just may have not liked any of > > them. > > > And, just a guess on why a business entity would do this... Google > > might just be a "different" company with some desire to help people > > instead of just maximizing profits. I don't know though. Beyond that, > > it might be a tax write-off to provide something usable for > > humanitarian issues (although I don't know the tax laws for that). > > > On May 16, 7:37 pm, gtandon <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > Google's initial ADC announcement that among other applications, they > > > would also be looking for humanitarian applications, or apps helping > > > economic development, was a bit surprising at first, but also > > > refreshing. This gave an impression that this business giant is also > > > looking at "doing good" with the challenge. > > > > But the following entry that was ranked in the lowest quartile for > > > every category (originality of this app is below the weather app) > > > broke all the illusion. > > > >http://groups.google.com/group/android-challenge/browse_thread/thread... > > > > At first I questioned why ADC put "humanitarian/economic development" > > > as a category. As a business entity what would google gain by putting > > > this as a category? I had answered my own question that Google does > > > everything different, and possibly it is doing so again. There is no > > > application from this category (except if we consider the family > > > safety type of apps) in the first 50. > > > > I want to find out how many applications submitted to ADC fall in this > > > category, and how they are ranked.- Hide quoted text - > > > - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text - --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Android Challenge" group. To post to this group, send email to android-challenge@googlegroups.com To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/android-challenge?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
