I'm in the same camp. I was just happy to get a 3D multiplayer game working correctly by the deadline. I spent the next week polishing it up and man have I found a ton of things that I wish I had gotten done in time for the contest. Obvious stuff like VBOs, mipmaps, better orientation handling, etc.. The game looks WAY better and runs 10-15 FPS faster on my G1 this week than it did when I submitted. Too bad I couldn't get it all in before the contest deadline!
On Sep 11, 4:36 pm, Tom Gibara <[email protected]> wrote: > I think lack of polish is a significant shortcoming in a large number of the > applications that are now available in the Android Market. There are lots of > great apps, and great apps that have very little polish (and perhaps don't > need it), but in general I think it's a quality that's in deficit. > Interestingly I think your blog post nails one the key reasons but which > your suggestions above won't remedy: > > Polish is better than feature. I found myself continually being tempted to > > > "add one more feature" to my entry, rather than spending what limited time > > that I did have working on smoothing out the UI bumps, testing, creating > > docs, designing appealing logos, making videos, testing, and oh yes, > > testing. > > I think authors really need to care about the user and their sum experience > of the application. And since resources are always finite, time spent adding > new features very soon subtracts significant time away from everything > that actually makes the features valuable to the user > (performance, reliability, comprehendiblity etc.) > > The things you list may or may not help, but in the end, they will simply > free up more developer time that will again go into more features and not > 'the other stuff' unless there's a change of priorities. > > Tom. > > 2009/9/11 dadical <[email protected]> > > > > > As I've wound down from the ADC2 adrenaline rush over the past few > > days, I've been thinking about a few things that I (re)-learned during > > the development of my entry. I blogged about it here: > > >http://keyeslabs.com/joomla/index.php/blogs/i-think-im-becoming-an-an... > > > The bottom line is that I think a lot of the software being written > > for Android right now lacks the basic polish that most users expect in > > software. ADC2 just seemed to exacerbate the problem with its tight > > deadlines. Beyond that, Google needs to start facilitating the > > creation of applications that meet users expectations. > > > I'll start the ball rolling by mentioning a few things that I think > > are missing: > > > 1. Marketplace for Android softwrae components. I hate having to > > develop UI views and widgets from scratch that I know other developers > > need too. I want a place to distribute/sell the cool views and > > widgets that I make, directly to developers. > > 2. APIs. Give me APIs, services, and views to polish my apps. > > - marketplace API > > - YouTube view that allows me to embed instuctional videos WITHIN > > my application > > - defect tracking services (Google code for commercial apps, with > > APIs please) > > - etc. > > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Android Developers" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/android-developers?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
