At 01:04 PM 5/1/2002 -0400, Erik Hatcher wrote:
You mean <copy includeemptydirs="true">, right?  <fileset> does not support
that attribute.

Yep. Should have said that these examples were off the top of my head and not tested.

Also, I was just briefly looking at the code to get a feel for it.  I see in
ContainsSelector.isSelected that it returns true without closing the file.
I'm assuming that it should, right?

It should always be closed by the finally block. The question for me in that code is whether catching an exception on close should throw an exception. If the close fails because the creation of the stream threw an exception, this throw may hide the real problem. OTOH, empty catch blocks are generally considered bad karma.

What does the combined wisdom of the Ant Dev mailing list think about this situation?


At 01:23 PM 5/1/2002 -0400, Erik Hatcher wrote:
They cannot be pre-defined and applied to multiple <fileset>'s, can they?
It doesn't appear this was taken into account though.

Well, some thought was given to it and there is some code to support it within containers. Your question caused me to write some tests for it and it turns out to be buggy, though. I've attached an updated BaseSelectorContainer.java which solves part of the problem, but for some reason the contained object fails as not being initialized. I can wrap all the calls to all attributes so that they check for references if that is necessary, but is it? Shouldn't the set of objects returned already have their attributes set? Colour me confused on this one. I've attached an updated build.xml to demonstrate the problem. With the corrected BaseSelectorContainer, test.ref.2 claims that the "contains" attribute hasn't been set.

Separate from this is whether selectors should be in types/defaults.properties. If that is considered a good thing, I think there should be a single container (<selector> which allows only one selector within it) rather than the full set of selectors defined under <project>. That is trivially done if desired. Perhaps for 1.6, though?

Attachment: build.xml
Description: application/xml


Attachment: BaseSelectorContainer.java
Description: Binary data


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Reply via email to