On Mon, 10 Jul 2006 23:18:37 +0200, Roman Kyrylych  
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

>> *confused* Wouldn't it just be ati and nvidia packages who would not  
>> work
>> with the new xorg in /testing(if 7.1 went there ofc)?
>
> Probably there will be others but these two are the most important
> because most users use them. Of course there are users who use nv,
> vmware, unichrome and other open-source drivers. But Xorg 7.1 does not
> brings any huge significant improvements for these users.
> So, at this point there is no need for upgrading to Xorg 7.1.
> I suppose that Nvidia and ATI will change their drivers soon. After
> that Xorg 7.1 will hit Testing. Bringing Xorg 7.1 to Testing right now
> does not give users anything significant (see above).
>

7.1 have numerous improvements:
http://ftp.x.org/pub/X11R7.1/doc/RELNOTES.html

atleast there were some i910(can't remember excactly) graphics users which
needed this new rel to be able to use X.

If those and other users need this rel isn't it our duty to put it in  
testing
causing us no havoc since we don't have to upgrade if we don't want to but  
those
users will get a working xorg off the bat.

Is it possible for pacman to post a warning message before clueless users  
upgrade
without thinking?

like pacman -Syu

[...]

Warning: If you upgrade to newest xorg, propriatory nvidia and ati  
graphics card
drivers will stop functioning and you will not be able to start the X  
server. Add
blabla to your IgnorePkg line ...

If people say this is windowsism they are not thinking about the fact that  
the
frontpage and bbs already provide these kind of warnings just in a dumber  
way,
because they doesn't reach as many people and require the user to visit  
forums,
stay uptodate etc etc. Which is a good thing, but unneded concerning this  
scenario.

-- 
Using Opera's revolutionary e-mail client: http://www.opera.com/mail/

_______________________________________________
arch mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.archlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/arch

Reply via email to