I SECOND SHAI! amazing thoughts, just what i was thinkin and more. it is so sad to read the stuff in here sometimes. a lot of times a r rahman and his music are the sole reason for my happiness apart from God. i could talk about rahman for hours yet it may seem as if i said nothing and got nowhere at all. :) that is how great he his.
--- In [email protected], ranga chary <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > wowwwwwwwww amazing thats what i feel too......thats SHAI and all the true RAHMANICs...if r think u really giving positive critics......please do stop that.....just imagine u r not RAHMAN himself....and i know perfectly well...he is not gonna listen to these so called critical evaluation of yours.....because he thinks 100 times (and faster than u, i can challenge u on that) before releasing any song or track.....listen.....every track!!!!!!!!! > thats what i feel and i dont wanna change it......cause HE is my breath....for this life..... > > urs never found, > RANGA, > RAHMANIC.. > > Krayzie B <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Wow..what a write up Shai..Hope all the bashers ,so called critique experts n whoeva said that ATM is not gudla,moderate la, nt 2 expection la, jz accept d fact dat notin is compared 2 ARR's music...Plzz stop all d craps n jz listen 2 d album..As for me,any sound dat point d name of ARR as d music director/composer its a gem...doesnt matter if its nt liked by sum group of ppl.As long its Rahmans name..its divine....Non of d fans has d credibility,knowledge n experience to giv comments 2 any of ARR's album...ok..plz bear dat in mind...The whole of the world is praising him...Its enough for a true fan..:)..Cheers rahmaniac...A WONDERFUL GIFT FOR DIWALI... > > Regards, > Suren.... > > Vithur <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Nicely written Shai. Rahman has been the best; will be the best always. ATM rocks.. My CD is gettign worn out .. > > > On 10/25/07, shai shai <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > everytime of a new ar rahman release i will come to the most hated moment in my life. > its about some people or maybe i should say fans.. > > before any ar rahman's film release there will be some fans telling 'i cant wait for the song'...please release it fast......'when is the release'..... > > but after the release.........all the words that i can see :...dissappointing'.....copied.......inspired.....'ar rahman not at his best....arr should have done better......this songs reminds me of old IR song....that song sounds like that....' > > what is the problem with this group?all of u are demanding something from one person called ar rahman....all of u are expecting something individually from one person called ar rahman again....and sadly all of ur expectations are different al together: > > some will expect song like roja > some will expect RDB kind > some will expect sivaji and some will expect uyire.....now which one would arr do > > none of u here are a director of the movie > none of u here are the producers > none of u here rajini,amir khan or vijay > none of u have given ar rahman the money to compose songs but > > u all are demanding,expecting,advising and giving instructions to ar rahman on how should he compose....how would i understand this.. > > is ar rahman a machine,keyboard or drums for u to expect many things from him...he is just a humble person playing keyboard,giving notes and trying very hard to satisfy his fans after AFTER going through all the demands of the producer,director and actors....with sleeples nights,tension,stress and all other things....and guess what are the responses and feedbacks that he will get by reading all those mails in this group? > > the funny thing happening in this group only this group is; > > ar rahman fans are the one will :praise him > :say they are dissappointed with his music > :say he copied and he inspired from other md > :expect tooo much and later dissappointed by that > : critic him > > all of this done by ar rahman fans AND NOT OTHER MUSIC DIRECTOR FANS... > > when one from this group tell that ar rahman copied or inspiredthey must know that they are the one who give information (rumours) about arr copied to other music director fans...and the other md fans will be happy to know that and will start bashing arrahman...and there will be HJ better than rahman,yuvan better than rahman and all those thing happened bcoz of? again ar rahman fans themselves....why guys why... > > we are the one should defend arr ,praise him...encourage him,give 10000% support...its ok if u dont do this but please dont do the other way around > > the difference between me and SOME other arr fans is::i sometimes will cry listening to ar rahman's music and thinking about him BUT some of u guys could make ar rahman cry ?reading ur mails > > > shai, > > not to all the fans BUT some?! > > > > > > > > > > Avinash: Thu Oct 25 03: 14: [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED];;;, ": Avinash :" < [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi... nice writeup man! Though it is written in a hurry, I loved and > agree with your all views!! > > --- In [email protected], "izham_jamal" <izham_jamal@> > wrote: > > > > Hi Dear ARR fans, > > I always visited this site but i usually dont post reply nor start > a > > new topic.But after i saw some comments made on ATM,i cant stay > quiet > > anymore.Since i started visiting this site,whenever a ARR album > > released,i saw someone WILL post some thing about > dissapointment.Its > > a complete nonsense.We have to understand that very2 few songs > that > > we like after the 1st hearing.Its a human nature,resistance to > accept > > new thing because they used to others,myb something like inertia > in > > physics terms.If we analyze ARR songs from those days to now,you > > hardly will found any similarities between the songs.We often like > > the earlier film music by ARR.As time goes when we heard the songs > > repeated times in TV or radio,then we will say,'hey this song is > not > > bad'.We are too curious waiting for his album,and we will listen > the > > new releases with a very-very high expectation which i think is > not > > fair to any music directors.Just think if we are not aware of ATM > > release and one day we heard it on the radio,im sure we will like > the > > song. > > > > Dear friends,we have to consider that this is a VJ film.We all > know > > how VJs film music will be like.Music directors cant simply create > a > > songs,it must caters the need of the director.Even ARR admit it > when > > he said i remember "you canot simply said ok we have ARR,the music > > gona be chartbuster,directors have to play their part aso to bring > > the best out of us(MD)".That is a very true statement indeed. > > > > Ok lets talk about ATM.Im not particularly like what we call as > gana > > or kuthu songs,so when ARR was signed 4 d movie,i realy wanted to > see > > how ARR music gone be,and he didnt dissapoint me at all.I know > some > > of us saying about lacking ARR touches on some of the songs,i can > > understand their feelings.SO i decided to make a review,not from > my > > point of view but from a neutral perspective considerin the > praises > > and critics received so far. > > > > 1.Ellapughalum > > -i cant recall a song that sung by ARR and havent become a hit.Hes > a > > gt a gifted voice as well.So far,VJ fans cant live without the > > song,for them its on of the best.This song dont take much time to > > grow on you.Top notch,so energetic and fantastic music.The critics > > received about this song is, too much instrument used in the > > backgrond and have similarities to ARRs Anbe Aauyire, i > think.Those > > who think like that,dont worry,it wont take much tile b4 u like > > it.Rating:9.5/10. > > > > 2.Poonmagal Remix > > -when i heard the sample release,i have to admit im a bit > > dissapointed as im expecting something like Thothal Poo > Malarum.After > > the full song released,i realy appreciate the creativeness of the > > maker(ARR or assistant),im sure many would agree with me.This song > > missing ARR touches,agreed,but we all know ARR not keen on Remixes > > and im sure hes a bit dissapointed when asked to remix the song > and > > rather asked his assistant to do it.Overall not bad,most people > gona > > love it.Rating:8.5/10. > > > > 3.Nee Marilyn Monroe. > > -i personally believe its one of ARR best western type of songs.I > jus > > cant get enough with it and my friends feeling the same way.I rely > > cant believe its done by ARR.Youthful lyrics and so relaxing to > > hear.Ok i agree it lacks ARR touches,but who cares,the song is > > rocking.Music is so beautiful and a good rap aso.The way words are > > pronounce are the strong point.Rating:9.0/10. > > > > 4.Valayapatti Thavil. > > -i tot its gona be another kamma karayil(varalaaru) after the > > sample.But actualy i lost my word,i cant rely classified this song > in > > any category.I think this is the only song i yet to heard any > critics > > and loved by almost everyone.This is not my pick of Album but > still > > its a very good song.Nothing much to said,the song talk for > > itself.Rating:9.5/10. > > > > 5.Maduraiku Pogadhe > > -VJ fans are happy but ARR fans are not.All in all folk song.I > dont > > realy like this kind of songs,but trust me,i loved it after > repeated > > hearings.No MD im sure cant do this type of song,even its a folk > > song, it has ARR maximum touch in it im sure.If you still dont > like > > then just ignore the song.Rating:8.5/10. > > > > 6.Kelamal Kayile > > -My favourite and im sure many have the same taste with me.Some > are > > saying it reminds us of Mellisaiye(mr.Romeo),till now i cant find > any > > basic to that.The male voice are top class and the female singer > even > > weird at times,but were vere quite good.We cant see some > experiment > > here,very high pitch of female voice at times that makes us > > uncomfortable,neverdles,its a great composition by ARR.Superb > music > > and different technic.Rating :9.0/10. > > > > FRIENDS,WHAT IS CLEAR HERE IS, LOWER YOUR EXPECTATION A BIT AND > > LISTEN TO THE SONG AS A NEUTRAL YOU WILL AND ENJOY THE SONG AS I > DID, > > RATHER THAN CRITICISE IT BECAUSE THIS ALBUM DIDNT DESERVES ANY > > CRITICS.I DONT RATE ANY SONG A PERFECT 10 COZ NOTHING IS PERFECT > EVEN > > IF IT LOOK LIKE IT. > > > > (Sory for any grammer or spelling mistakes,i took some time to > write > > this as im not a good typer,im hapy if you al can give your tot > abt > > this.Thank You.) > > > > > > > __________________________________________________ > Do You Yahoo!? > Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around > http://mail.yahoo.com > > > > > > > > > > > -- > regards, > Vithur > > A.R. RAHMAN - THE GOD OF MUSIC > > > __________________________________________________ > Do You Yahoo!? > Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around > http://mail.yahoo.com > > > > > *************************************************** > "WE KNOW WHAT WE ARE, BUT NOT WHAT WE CAN BECOME." > WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE > > *************************************************** > > urs always, > chary. > > V.RANGADHARA CHARY. > M.Tech MME, > SOLID STATE PHASE RESIDENCE: > TRANSFORMATION LAB, B 313,HALL 5, > IIT KANPUR, IIT KANPUR. > INDIA. > __________________________________________________ > Do You Yahoo!? > Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around > http://mail.yahoo.com >
