well by one line I did not literally mean one line but a very small portion of the song. it is a Sonu song mainly, Shreya does not have a full part in it as in regular duet songs.
> Please get your facts right > Infact she shares half the song. infact the same comment I should make for you. it is certainly not "half the song" as you said either. in a 6:10 minutes song, she enters at 3:44 and barely gets 70 seconds to sing in whole. now i don't think it can be called "half the song". and by the way if you mind me saying she won national award for one line, would it be okay if i say she won it for 70 seconds?? > And it says that she won for apne aasoo ke liye. Is it the same song? Yes it is the same song. i dont know why exactly but perhaps they named it "Apne Aansoo Peene Ke Liye" because this is the line she sings in the song. you can confirm at the links below: http://www.hindu.com/fr/2007/08/10/stories/2007081050560100.htm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paheli - Jahanzeb --- In [email protected], "Gomzy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Please get your facts right. She has sung more than a line. Infact she > shares half the song. > And it says that she won for apne aasoo ke liye. Is it the same song? > > On Mon, Nov 24, 2008 at 12:23 AM, V S Rawat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > On 11/23/2008 8:08 PM India Time, _Jahanzeb Farooq_ wrote: > > > > > talking about Shreya, did you forget that out of the world rendering > > > she did in "Dheerey Jalna" from Paheli? It was actually a Sonu Nigam > > > song (and one of his best sung songs I believe), Shreya has only one > > > line to sing in it and you know what, she won national award for that > > > song. that one lone of her was so soulful, so wonderful, so out of the > > > world, cannot express in words. > > > > I was not aware of that that she got a national award for a single line. > > > > That is really great. > > > > Thanks for sharing this info, Farooq. > > > > among non-ARR song, in the legendary Pakeezah, there was a song Chalo > > Dildar Chalo, Chaand ke paar chalo that was a duet but only this part > > "Chalo Dildar Chalo, Chaand ke paar chalo" was rendered by Rafi and rest > > of the song, all stanza were fully by Lata. Still it had come out such a > > beautiful song. > > > > -- > > Rawat > > > > > --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > > Indmov Buff <indmovbuff@> > > > wrote: > > >> I've listened to the songs 14 times (and will keep going) but it > > > looks like we've been exposed to more of ARR's take on bollywood > > > masala (especially with Lattoo and Aye Bachu). > > >> One track that I want to talk about is Kaise Mujhe. I wrote it off > > > in the first listen but then I kept going back to it for Shreya's > > > portion. WOW! I mean, how can one human being evoke the soulfulness > > > that she does in this song? Unbelievable. In just 1 min and 30 seconds > > > too?! I don't know about awards but I want to give her a massive hug > > > just for the humming that she does when she enters. It is beautiful, > > > passionate and soulful. I wished Benny's vocals didn't sound as > > > strained as they do in parts of the track but I guess that's supposed > > > to add to the mood perhaps. I feel like I've sinned now by making a > > > negative comment about this song. This song to me is all about > > > Shreya's bit. Period. > > >> Wasn't that impressed with Bekha after the promo (the visuals didn't > > > help either) but I am loving this one now. The inter-woven melody is > > > awesome and who better to do it than Karthik. To me he sounded like > > > SPB in bits of this song. anyone else felt this? > > >> Hope all of you are re-discovering this piece with the same (or > > > more) excitement it has brought me today. > > > > > > >
