well by one line I did not literally mean one line but a very small portion of the song. it is a Sonu song mainly, Shreya does not have a full part in it as in regular duet songs.
> Please get your facts right infact the same comment I should make for you. it is certainly not "half the song" as you said either. in a 6:10 minutes song, she enters at 3:44 and barely gets 70 seconds to sing in whole. now i don't think it can be called "half the song". and by the way if you mind me saying she won national award for one line, would it be okay if i say she won it for 70 seconds?? > And it says that she won for apne aasoo ke liye. Is it the same song? Yes it is the same song. i dont know exactly but perhaps they named it "Apne Aansoo Peene Ke Liye" because this is the line she sings in the song. you can confirm at the links below: http://www.hindu.com/fr/2007/08/10/stories/2007081050560100.htm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paheli - Jahanzeb --- In [email protected], "Gomzy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Please get your facts right. She has sung more than a line. Infact she > shares half the song. > And it says that she won for apne aasoo ke liye. Is it the same song? > > On Mon, Nov 24, 2008 at 12:23 AM, V S Rawat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > On 11/23/2008 8:08 PM India Time, _Jahanzeb Farooq_ wrote: > > > > > talking about Shreya, did you forget that out of the world rendering > > > she did in "Dheerey Jalna" from Paheli? It was actually a Sonu Nigam > > > song (and one of his best sung songs I believe), Shreya has only one > > > line to sing in it and you know what, she won national award for that > > > song. that one lone of her was so soulful, so wonderful, so out of the > > > world, cannot express in words. > > > > I was not aware of that that she got a national award for a single line. > > > > That is really great. > > > > Thanks for sharing this info, Farooq. > > > > among non-ARR song, in the legendary Pakeezah, there was a song Chalo > > Dildar Chalo, Chaand ke paar chalo that was a duet but only this part > > "Chalo Dildar Chalo, Chaand ke paar chalo" was rendered by Rafi and rest > > of the song, all stanza were fully by Lata. Still it had come out such a > > beautiful song. > > > > -- > > Rawat > > > > > --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > > Indmov Buff <indmovbuff@> > > > wrote: > > >> I've listened to the songs 14 times (and will keep going) but it > > > looks like we've been exposed to more of ARR's take on bollywood > > > masala (especially with Lattoo and Aye Bachu). > > >> One track that I want to talk about is Kaise Mujhe. I wrote it off > > > in the first listen but then I kept going back to it for Shreya's > > > portion. WOW! I mean, how can one human being evoke the soulfulness > > > that she does in this song? Unbelievable. In just 1 min and 30 seconds > > > too?! I don't know about awards but I want to give her a massive hug > > > just for the humming that she does when she enters. It is beautiful, > > > passionate and soulful. I wished Benny's vocals didn't sound as > > > strained as they do in parts of the track but I guess that's supposed > > > to add to the mood perhaps. I feel like I've sinned now by making a > > > negative comment about this song. This song to me is all about > > > Shreya's bit. Period. > > >> Wasn't that impressed with Bekha after the promo (the visuals didn't > > > help either) but I am loving this one now. The inter-woven melody is > > > awesome and who better to do it than Karthik. To me he sounded like > > > SPB in bits of this song. anyone else felt this? > > >> Hope all of you are re-discovering this piece with the same (or > > > more) excitement it has brought me today. > > > > > > >
