Did they listen to Mausam and Escape at all?
--- In [email protected], ber...@... wrote: > > Its pity on them... > See my blog titled "Pity" at www.berginroy.com > > - Bergin > > Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T > > -----Original Message----- > From: "nivensamy" <niven...@...> > > Date: Wed, 04 Feb 2009 10:29:06 > To: <[email protected]> > Subject: [arr] Re: 'What has Rahman done in Slumdog Millionaire to get an Oscar nomination?' > > > Ha,,,Ha.,,,Ha.... > > Im starting to find fun in these articles about negative critics on > slumdog. Instead of retaliating, im finding fun in it. And I recommend > same to all rahmaniacs. LOL, Negative articles about our Boss were so > rare.. Let's enjoy LOL > > Niven > > > --- In [email protected], "rayrai2k" <ravisdev@> wrote: > > > > If I happen to meet this lady I will definitely ask her a question? > > what makes her to be in Whistling Woods despite such a > > mediocre "Yuvvaraaj". And I will definitely post her answers if I > > get. > > > > --- In [email protected], Gomzy� <gomtesh.upadhye@> > > wrote: > > > > > > *Keep your cool guys! * > > > > > > ** > > > > > > * > > > http://specials.rediff.com/movies/2009/feb/02sl1-why-you-should-not- > > watch-slumdog.htm > > > * > > > > > > *Shamal Sengupta, who teaches direction at Subhash Ghai's filmmaking > > > institute Whistling Woods in Mumbai, tells us why he disliked > > Slumdog > > > Millionaire.* > > > > > > ** > > > > > > *'What has Rahman done in Slumdog Millionaire to get an Oscar > > nomination?'* > > > **S*lumdog* will definitely bag an Oscar or two. But that would > > be a > > > shame. The sanctity of the Oscars was lost long ago, so *Slumdog* > > will not > > > the only film that will show it down. There are many other films > > that > > > deserve it more. > > > > > > I must mention A R Rahman. *What has he done in Slumdog Millionaire > > to get > > > an Oscar nomination?* He is such a great musician, he has composed > > better > > > music in other films. I am sure that he knows himself that he has > > done a > > > very mediocre job here. > > > > > > *The background score is a disaster. The song Jai Ho and its > > picturisation > > > is another disaster.* Why did the song need to be in the film? What > > a waste! > > > It was very unnecessary for that song to be in the film; more so, > > to be shot > > > in Chhatrapati Shivaji Terminus. > > > > > > *'I don't think a film like this will ruin our country's worth'* > > > > > > *Rahman will get his cheque and continue making music and > > entertaining us. > > > But the question is why waste your talent for money?* > > > > > > Portraying India this way gives a very bad taste. India has always > > been > > > looked upon from the fixed viewpoints of poverty, prostitution, > > crime, > > > superstition and blind beliefs. > > > > > > But let me also tell you what I liked about the film. The technical > > aspects > > > like camera work, shooting locations, and location management were > > well > > > done. I will definitely show this film to my students to teach them > > camera > > > angles. > > > > > > I am not being patriotic, I am just being reasonable. I don't think > > a film > > > like this will ruin our country's worth. I think the world knows > > that India > > > is not just about poverty and crime but has much more value than > > that. > > > > > > Full Article > > > > > >
