On 2/27/2009 4:38 PM India Time, _dhina_arr_ wrote: > If ARR has not introduced Sukhi some other music director would have > done that.... same way if sukhi has not sung JAI HO some other > singer would have sung that..even ARR could have.. who knows.. > > The Song won the award because of the tune,music... not because of > Sukhi or Gulzar...i don't think academy members know hindi to > understand the Lyrics.. > > So the credit for JAI HO's win should go to ARR only... Gulzar won > because he was part of it.. if any other lyricsist would have > written the song they would be the winner now..
This type of logic would earn reverse logic that if any other composer (not ARR) would have composed the song and album, he would be the winner now.. > > just my thaught.. not offending Sukhi or gulzar.. It was bound to happen. Now we ARR fans are growing so miser that we are trying to steal credit from others - even from Gulzar sab, who HAS WON AN OSCAR like ARR has won. It always happen that the person getting the Oscar doesn't say, not even thinks any of these, but it is the supporters and fans who start laying such "solo" claims. It is a bad day of this list. -- Rawat
