hi chord,
i should tell you clearly i never included water and guru in the list
of mediocre albums of a r rahman. these two movies have superior songs no doubt
about it . the songs amazed me, surprised me and gave me a life time feeling ,
but the movies i am talking about had no effect on me at all, they didnt amazed
, surprised, and most importantly they didnt develop any beautiful feelings in
me. and i am listing those movies.
1)rang de basanti
2)jodha akbar
3)jaane tu jaaane na
4)ada
5)yuvraaj
6)ghajini
7)dilli 6
i should tell you all these movies have made A R RAHMAN really popular in the
masses atleast in Pakistan, and people really like his music now . but the man
who is in love with his music since childhood just dont like the songs in
these albums at all. they are nowhere near to the legendary songs that A R
RAHAN HAD PRODUCED over the years. they are low standard songs , can be
compared with the songs of any other music director, which i just dont want
with A RRAHMANs music. he is the greatest musician for me , i cant see him
making such mediocre songs simple as that.
regards,
taimur,
karachi,
Pakistan.
--- In [email protected], "ichord" <purev...@...> wrote:
>
> Yeah, I know, I was just playing around.
>
>
> --- In [email protected], Gomzy <gomtesh.upadhye@> wrote:
> >
> > Chord,
> >
> > Its not worth it. Some people. Let them be.
> >
> > On Mon, Aug 31, 2009 at 7:20 AM, ichord <purevibz@> wrote:
> >
> > >
> > >
> > > Taimur, you said,
> > >
> > > "i hurt a lot of people by saying RDB a flop but i just dont like those
> > > simple tunes and ordinary stuff. And since then its all the same."
> > >
> > > So, let me just clarify....since the song Rasiya from MP, you think that
> > > every song that ARR has created in Hindi is ordinary, sound similar to one
> > > another, nothing creative, nothing special...am I right? So, when you come
> > > down to it...I'm going to list my fav songs since MP and try to understand
> > > what you're saying: Oh, you also said that pretty much every song in Tamil
> > > within this time span is superior to any of these songs below (hey, I got
> > > some time on my hands and want to have some boring fun, so here goes.....)
> > >
> > > - Tu Bin Bataye (RDB) - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - Piya Ho (Water - post MP) - nothing special, non creative, ordinary,
> > > same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - Chan Chan (Water)- nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - Naina Neer (Water) - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - Ru Ba Ru - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Khoon Chala - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > > - Lukha Chuppi - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > > - Tere Bina - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > >
> > > - Jaage - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Ay Hairathe - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > > - Khwaja Mere Khwaja - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - Man Mohanna - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > > - Azeem O Shan Shehenshah - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - In Lamhon Ke - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > > - Meherbaan - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > >
> > > - Ishq Ada Hai ( male and female) - nothing special, non creative,
> > > ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Kabhi Kabhi Aditi - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - To Bole - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Jaane Tu Mera Kya Hai (male and female) - nothing special, non creative,
> > > ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Zindagi - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Man Mohiney More - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - Muskura - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Dil Ka Rishta - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > > - Guzarish - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Kaise Mujhe - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > > - Bekha - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Masakali - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Rehna Tu - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Arziyan - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Dil Gira Dafatan - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same
> > > sounding, bland
> > > - Delhi 6 - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland
> > > - Genda Phool - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding,
> > > bland
> > >
> > > Well, if everyone agreed with you that all the songs above sound the same,
> > > are ordinary, are bland, are non creative, there must be something
> > > seriously
> > > wrong with my ears.
> > >
> > > Thanks.
> > >
> > > --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>,
> > > Taimur Nadeem <taimur.nadeem@> wrote:
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > Hi vinu,
> > > > O man so nice of you, you made my day by saying me diehard
> > > Rahmaniac. where others are telling me to leave the group or describing me
> > > as a person with a fake ID, some even telling me about being non tamil and
> > > foreign person , but i accept each comment no problems.
> > > >
> > > > You know it has been three years since i loved an A R RAHMAN hindi song.
> > > i have grown up on the rhythm of A R RAHMAN songs. i still remember i was
> > > only 8 years old in 1995 when Bombay, Hum Se Hai Muqabla got released , i
> > > liked the music of the songs not knowing who have made them or what they
> > > are. then Rangeela , Hindustani came , i loved the music again without
> > > knowing A R RAHMAN. Then in 1998 Dil se came i was 11 years old at that
> > > time , i was blown up by the music. i remember when i first listened dil
> > > se
> > > re , i rewinded the cassette and listened it 16 more times . here i got to
> > > know A R RAHMAN and MANI RATNAM ( my favourite director). then it all
> > > started, it was so great , i used to wait anxiously for A R RAHMAN album
> > > and
> > > A R RAHMAN always surprised me with his music.
> > > >
> > > > but now i find his tracks very ordinary , i have no problem with TAMIL
> > > songs although i dont understand them i love the latest albums ,
> > > AZHAGIYA
> > > TAMIL MAGAN was great and i loved sakkarakati. but hindi songs not a
> > > single
> > > song in past three years the last song i loved was RASIYA from Mangal
> > > Panday.
> > > >
> > > > i hurt a lot of people by saying RDB a flop but i just dont like those
> > > simple tunes and ordinary stuff.And since then its all the same.
> > > >
> > > > I know A R RAHMAN will once again show his wizardry and class but till
> > > then i am waiting...
> > > >
> > > > regards,
> > > >
> > > > Taimur,
> > > > Karachi,
> > > > Pakistan.
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> >
>
