Yes, I understood. I think I misworded/ommitted what I wanted to say. I meant to say Water and Guru are suddenly now included in the albums that he likes, meaning he backtracked.
--- In [email protected], V S Rawat <vsra...@...> wrote: > > chord, > > Did you at all read what he is writing? > > He writes very clearly "i NEVER included water and guru in the list of > mediocre albums" > > -- > Rawat > > On 9/1/2009 12:15 AM India Time, _ichord_ wrote: > > > Now you've backtracked.....first since Rasiya, nothing special, but now > > Guru and Water included.... I disagree with you completely, but that's > > fine. It's your opinion. I think AR himself would disagree with you too, > > calling his latest work mediocre, low standard, sounding like the rest of > > the pack. I think he would be somewhat hurt too if he read what you said. > > I honestly don't see at the very least how you think albums like Jodha > > Akbar, Yuvvraaj, and Delhi 6 sound like the rest of the pack. But hey, I'm > > not you...and we do have freedom of speech. > > > > --- In [email protected], "taimur.nadeem" <taimur.nadeem@> wrote: > >> > >> hi chord, > >> i should tell you clearly i never included water and guru in the > >> list of mediocre albums of a r rahman. these two movies have superior > >> songs no doubt about it . the songs amazed me, surprised me and gave me a > >> life time feeling , but the movies i am talking about had no effect on me > >> at all, they didnt amazed , surprised, and most importantly they didnt > >> develop any beautiful feelings in me. and i am listing those movies. > >> > >> 1)rang de basanti > >> 2)jodha akbar > >> 3)jaane tu jaaane na > >> 4)ada > >> 5)yuvraaj > >> 6)ghajini > >> 7)dilli 6 > >> > >> i should tell you all these movies have made A R RAHMAN really popular in > >> the masses atleast in Pakistan, and people really like his music now . but > >> the man who is in love with his music since childhood just dont like the > >> songs in these albums at all. they are nowhere near to the legendary songs > >> that A R RAHAN HAD PRODUCED over the years. they are low standard songs , > >> can be compared with the songs of any other music director, which i just > >> dont want with A RRAHMANs music. he is the greatest musician for me , i > >> cant see him making such mediocre songs simple as that. > >> > >> regards, > >> > >> taimur, > >> karachi, > >> Pakistan. > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> --- In [email protected], "ichord" <purevibz@> wrote: > >>> Yeah, I know, I was just playing around. > >>> > >>> > >>> --- In [email protected], Gomzy� <gomtesh.upadhye@> wrote: > >>>> Chord, > >>>> > >>>> Its not worth it. Some people. Let them be. > >>>> > >>>> On Mon, Aug 31, 2009 at 7:20 AM, ichord <purevibz@> wrote: > >>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> Taimur, you said, > >>>>> > >>>>> "i hurt a lot of people by saying RDB a flop but i just dont like those > >>>>> simple tunes and ordinary stuff. And since then its all the same." > >>>>> > >>>>> So, let me just clarify....since the song Rasiya from MP, you think that > >>>>> every song that ARR has created in Hindi is ordinary, sound similar to > >>>>> one > >>>>> another, nothing creative, nothing special...am I right? So, when you > >>>>> come > >>>>> down to it...I'm going to list my fav songs since MP and try to > >>>>> understand > >>>>> what you're saying: Oh, you also said that pretty much every song in > >>>>> Tamil > >>>>> within this time span is superior to any of these songs below (hey, I > >>>>> got > >>>>> some time on my hands and want to have some boring fun, so here > >>>>> goes.....) > >>>>> > >>>>> - Tu Bin Bataye (RDB) - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - Piya Ho (Water - post MP) - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, > >>>>> same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - Chan Chan (Water)- nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - Naina Neer (Water) - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - Ru Ba Ru - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Khoon Chala - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Lukha Chuppi - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Tere Bina - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> > >>>>> - Jaage - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland > >>>>> - Ay Hairathe - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Khwaja Mere Khwaja - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - Man Mohanna - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Azeem O Shan Shehenshah - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, > >>>>> same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - In Lamhon Ke - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Meherbaan - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> > >>>>> - Ishq Ada Hai ( male and female) - nothing special, non creative, > >>>>> ordinary, same sounding, bland > >>>>> - Kabhi Kabhi Aditi - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - To Bole - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Jaane Tu Mera Kya Hai (male and female) - nothing special, non > >>>>> creative, > >>>>> ordinary, same sounding, bland > >>>>> - Zindagi - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Man Mohiney More - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - Muskura - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Dil Ka Rishta - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same > >>>>> sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Guzarish - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Kaise Mujhe - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Bekha - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, bland > >>>>> - Masakali - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Rehna Tu - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Arziyan - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Dil Gira Dafatan - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same > >>>>> sounding, bland > >>>>> - Delhi 6 - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> - Genda Phool - nothing special, non creative, ordinary, same sounding, > >>>>> bland > >>>>> > >>>>> Well, if everyone agreed with you that all the songs above sound the > >>>>> same, > >>>>> are ordinary, are bland, are non creative, there must be something > >>>>> seriously > >>>>> wrong with my ears. > >>>>> > >>>>> Thanks. > >>>>> > >>>>> --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > >>>>> Taimur Nadeem <taimur.nadeem@> wrote: > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Hi vinu, > >>>>>> O man so nice of you, you made my day by saying me diehard > >>>>> Rahmaniac. where others are telling me to leave the group or describing > >>>>> me > >>>>> as a person with a fake ID, some even telling me about being non tamil > >>>>> and > >>>>> foreign person , but i accept each comment no problems. > >>>>>> You know it has been three years since i loved an A R RAHMAN hindi > >>>>>> song. > >>>>> i have grown up on the rhythm of A R RAHMAN songs. i still remember i > >>>>> was > >>>>> only 8 years old in 1995 when Bombay, Hum Se Hai Muqabla got released , > >>>>> i > >>>>> liked the music of the songs not knowing who have made them or what they > >>>>> are. then Rangeela , Hindustani came , i loved the music again without > >>>>> knowing A R RAHMAN. Then in 1998 Dil se came i was 11 years old at that > >>>>> time , i was blown up by the music. i remember when i first listened > >>>>> dil se > >>>>> re , i rewinded the cassette and listened it 16 more times . here i got > >>>>> to > >>>>> know A R RAHMAN and MANI RATNAM ( my favourite director). then it all > >>>>> started, it was so great , i used to wait anxiously for A R RAHMAN > >>>>> album and > >>>>> A R RAHMAN always surprised me with his music. > >>>>>> but now i find his tracks very ordinary , i have no problem with TAMIL > >>>>> songs although i dont understand them i love the latest albums , > >>>>> AZHAGIYA > >>>>> TAMIL MAGAN was great and i loved sakkarakati. but hindi songs not a > >>>>> single > >>>>> song in past three years the last song i loved was RASIYA from Mangal > >>>>> Panday. > >>>>>> i hurt a lot of people by saying RDB a flop but i just dont like those > >>>>> simple tunes and ordinary stuff.And since then its all the same. > >>>>>> I know A R RAHMAN will once again show his wizardry and class but till > >>>>> then i am waiting... > >>>>>> regards, > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Taimur, > >>>>>> Karachi, > >>>>>> Pakistan. >
