Honestly, but this is just my opinion... i hae no problems with the High Notes segment ranking of Delhi 6 below DEv D and what's your raashee. Planet Bollywood i have found to be genuine in their assessment of music coming form the Hindi industry. I can understand Dev D and What's Your Raashee being higher than Delhi 6 on the grounds that to the general public...there where little expectations...the music is by newcomers and so blew everyone away. Rahman has already made his mark and expectations are always going to be high...and sometimes a bit diffucult to meet as Blue was. I expected good music from both new individuals Amit Trivedi (who was excellent in his first piece Aamir) and Sohail Sen who did a good song in his first venture Sirf. As a fan of music, all of these albums would be dear to me and I would not rnk one higher over the other...Hence I am not bothered t the end of the day music won. More than a fan of Rahman, I am a fan of Good music and it was being a fan of good music that made me a fan of Rahman. That is me... everyone is entitled to their own views. Vedavid.
--- On Thu, 1/7/10, Rivjot <[email protected]> wrote: From: Rivjot <[email protected]> Subject: [arr] Re: PB's High Notes of 2009 - Delhi 6 at Number 3?? To: [email protected] Date: Thursday, January 7, 2010, 1:33 AM Read - "Note: Aakash Gandhi, our Managing Editor and founder of this popular feature was sadly unable to write this piece for 2009. However the excellent news is that we are expecting him back sometime soon in 2010 so watch this space!" Surely he would have placed Delhi-6 on number 1. I liked both Dev D and Raashee music, in personal ranking I would place them below D6 and above Blue (from 2009 music). I am predicting Amit Trivedi will win RD Burman award of upcoming music talent (for Dev D) this year.. and hoping Rahman will win best music for D6. @ ichord - Interestingly you didnt say anything about Blue (placed on # 13) because if I recall you just loved that album. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, "ichord" <purev...@.. .> wrote: > > Music of "What's Your Rashee" and "Dev D" better than Delhi 6? Yes, according > to this author in PB. Do I agree? HECK NO!!!!! Delhi 6 is by far and ahead > the best album of 2009!!!!!! This it not to take away the recognition of good > music of the other 2 soundtracks. > > He criticizes D6, saying that besides the 4 biggies, the other songs are > short and situational and that D6 title song and Bandar are disappointing. My > friend, did you forget the rage of Genda Phool? People love that song, even > voting it as the best in some online rankings! As far as I remember, people > loved the D6 title song too. > > Oh well, it's only his opinion and we shouldn't get too wound up about it. > When it comes to awards time, we will know which album really ruled in 2009!! > > http://www.planetbo llywood.com/ displayArticle. php?id=s01011008 0412 >
