I respect your views.
--- In [email protected], vedavid manick <vedavid_man...@...> wrote:
>
> Honestly, but this is just my opinion... i hae no problems with the High
> Notes segment ranking of Delhi 6 below DEv D and what's your raashee.
> Â
> Planet Bollywood i have found to be genuine in their assessment of music
> coming form the Hindi industry.
> Â
> I can understand Dev D and What's Your Raashee being higher than Delhi 6 on
> the grounds that to the general public...there where little
> expectations...the music is by newcomers and so blew everyone away. Rahman
> has already made his mark and expectations are always going to be high...and
> sometimes a bit diffucult to meet as Blue was.
> Â
> I expected good music from both new individuals Amit Trivedi (who was
> excellent in his first piece Aamir) and Sohail Sen who did a good song in his
> first venture Sirf.
> Â
> As a fan of music, all of these albums would be dear to me and I would not
> rnk one higher over the other...Hence I am not bothered t the end of the day
> music won. More than a fan of Rahman, I am a fan of Good music and it was
> being a fan of good music that made me a fan of Rahman.
> Â
> That is me... everyone is entitled to their own views.
> Â
> Vedavid.
>
> --- On Thu, 1/7/10, Rivjot <riv...@...> wrote:
>
>
> From: Rivjot <riv...@...>
> Subject: [arr] Re: PB's High Notes of 2009 - Delhi 6 at Number 3??
> To: [email protected]
> Date: Thursday, January 7, 2010, 1:33 AM
>
>
> Â
>
>
>
> Read - "Note: Aakash Gandhi, our Managing Editor and founder of this popular
> feature was sadly unable to write this piece for 2009. However the excellent
> news is that we are expecting him back sometime soon in 2010 so watch this
> space!"
>
> Surely he would have placed Delhi-6 on number 1.
> I liked both Dev D and Raashee music, in personal ranking I would place them
> below D6 and above Blue (from 2009 music). I am predicting Amit Trivedi will
> win RD Burman award of upcoming music talent (for Dev D) this year.. and
> hoping Rahman will win best music for D6.
>
> @ ichord - Interestingly you didnt say anything about Blue (placed on # 13)
> because if I recall you just loved that album.
>
> --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, "ichord" <purevibz@ .> wrote:
> >
> > Music of "What's Your Rashee" and "Dev D" better than Delhi 6? Yes,
> > according to this author in PB. Do I agree? HECK NO!!!!! Delhi 6 is by far
> > and ahead the best album of 2009!!!!!! This it not to take away the
> > recognition of good music of the other 2 soundtracks.
> >
> > He criticizes D6, saying that besides the 4 biggies, the other songs are
> > short and situational and that D6 title song and Bandar are disappointing.
> > My friend, did you forget the rage of Genda Phool? People love that song,
> > even voting it as the best in some online rankings! As far as I remember,
> > people loved the D6 title song too.
> >
> > Oh well, it's only his opinion and we shouldn't get too wound up about it.
> > When it comes to awards time, we will know which album really ruled in
> > 2009!!
> >
> > http://www.planetbo llywood.com/ displayArticle. php?id=s01011008 0412
> >
>
