Roshan, You wrote a good post. I agree with you 100%. Not only will these accusations not help Rahman, he will feel hurt inside if he sees them in this group. He will not feel hurt if we criticize his album constructively, but he will feel hurt if we accuse him of being any of the selfish statements that have been written lately.
Please guys, stop this "ARR has lost it" nonsense. Please!!!! If you don't like an album, fine, but stop there. --- In [email protected], "coolwiz80" <siris...@...> wrote: > > Well written dude. You can add one more to the list of accusations - > > 6 - He's doing way too many hindi films and so not concentrating Tamil. In > short, he should stop working in hindi films, a request which I hate hearing > in this group. > > If he had done that he'd never have given us Delhi 6, Jodhaa Akbar, JTYJN and > many more masterpieces. > > Sirish > > --- In [email protected], Roshan <c.pixels@> wrote: > > > > to all those who think that this group doesn't welcome criticism, > > > > Ask yourself the question, were you really criticizing his music or were you > > just plainly accusing that he hasn't been good lately ? those are two > > entirely different things. > > > > if you want to criticize, make it constructive.. pouring negativity in a > > mail and putting a load of superlative words, your own definition of "true > > fan", whatever, in to it to make it look like you have been loving him more > > than yourself but AR rahman just betrayed you... is not what is called a > > constructive criticism. > > > > But the fact is that you have been loving only yourself! You listen to his > > music for your own pleasure. And when you think you can't be pleased with > > his music because a certain style of music is not of your liking, you accuse > > him of betraying you. Where I come from, we call it being selfish. > > > > let's look at what you all have been accusing him of > > > > 1 - lost touch due to tours and live programs > > 2 - He didn't compose Puli's music but Ranjit Barot did. > > 3 - AR Rahman is now more into social networking and iPads than music. > > 4 - AR doesn't care about his fans > > 5 - AR Rahman used to make better music in his early days than now. > > > > > > will any of these accusations help him improve his music or career ? a big > > fat NO! > > >
