Hello Mr. Sanket, Critcism is not immature. Who told u that. who are u to tell me not to buy ARR audios. That none of ur business. I m here not to fight. I only expressed my opinion. VTV was a superb album. Those who think Blue, Parasuram, Udaya, Puli are superb songs they dont know the ABCD of music and ARR' s talent. Check all his past records. Even Ravan some songs are good. Also Mani ratnam didnt utilised well. I was very proud when my friends tell the Talent of ARR on those, even my family also a great fan FAN of ARR. Even my mother tell now he sounds repetative. If the group blocks me for this email, I ve no regrets. A true fan is the one who must tell him the weakness. When ARR was doing periodic films fans complainted him to stop doing those films. what happened now, he stopped. He must give dates to all upcoming new directors. Wishes for ARR for Endiran, also waiting for the audio release with variety music. Regards Naveen
--- On Sun, 7/18/10, sanket joshi <[email protected]> wrote: From: sanket joshi <[email protected]> Subject: Re: [arr] Lost Touch due to Tours and Live Programms To: [email protected] Date: Sunday, July 18, 2010, 6:56 PM Dear all, as evident from Ranjit's mail and also previous discussions about criticizing Rahman's music where I was also at the receiving end (becuase I said "let us accept"..for which i sincerely apologize) it is clear that if somebody doesn't like Rahman's album then he should either keep mum or go on praising the album more every time! this is the only reason why this group exists.. So dear Naveen and me and some of you who MAY feel like us, Dont ever dare open your mouth to criticize Rahman's album! the Critics are all immature...they dont understand his music....because even if you liked his music till date and now if you feel that his music is not creating that magic, sorry guys, leave the group...(sad. .i also have to leave the group..hmm) Thanks and regards, SANEKT P.S. was it harsh Ranjit! Sorry, had to let is out! From: Roshan <c.pix...@gmail. com> To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Sun, July 18, 2010 4:30:23 PM Subject: Re: [arr] Lost Touch due to Tours and Live Programms On Sat, Jul 17, 2010 at 12:51 PM, Ranjit k <yseri...@yahoo. com> wrote: Naveen Pillai, I completely agree with you. If you two like to engage in some kind of love affair, keep it to yourself.. send your pathetic mails to him directly. It happens in everyone's life and every career in this world, where one is about to slip into deep forest from where you might not come back at all. This is happening with ARR also. Its time he realises that Look at where the music is going in Hindi film industry. Whom do u want me to name, Shankar-Eshaan- Loy, Mithoon, Pritam, Salim-Sulaiman, Amit Trivedi and the list is endless. In Tamil, look at what Yuvan does and in Telugu look at Mickey J Meyer. All the above mentioned music directors are very promising. They never let the fan's expectations down. They might not have got Oscars, but they respect a fan. wow! and you are saying AR doesn't respect his fans ? they are all fantastic musicians.. but you are a pathetic fan. In any industry, this is the rule, either you give your best or just move out. It is high time that ARR wakes up. Instead of focussing on Twitter, iPad, or Social networking sites and letting down great directors like Mani Rathnam, take a break and come back to who you really are. he has been giving his best since the days of roja.. it's just that you are so biased and have some kind of agenda to flood this group with hate mails. so, for you, it all seems like he is now showing off his twitter, ipad and facebook abilities.. But for us, it seems like he is honestly trying to connect with the fans. You said he doesn't respect his fans, didn't you.. You failed to see the possibilities of social networking and how great it can be a tool to connect with your listeners again, you are so biased. not only towards AR rahman but also towards all these things you mentioned. twitter, ipad (seriously ? ipad ? what does that has got to do with this ?) and social networking. I don't blame you though.. it happens to people who still live in stone age and refuse to come out that cage. So, my advice to you man, go back to where you belong and just don't bring your hate mails to this group. Look at Puli, what a pathetic music. How do I go around to my non-telugu fans and say that this is the music I listen to and say I am a proud ARR fan. It just makes me rethink if I should be proud. Look at yourself.. what a pathetic whiner you are! why do you think it is necessary for you to go around to your non-telugu fans. do you really have fans ? wow! no one asked you to be so proud to be arr fan. he is better off without you as a fan. I know it is a lot of criticism, but if I, as an ARR fan, do not have this right to express what I feel, then this forum is useless for me. i don't really see much of criticism here. you didn't analyze his music or said anything about what went wrong. you simply accused him of embracing technology more than music and letting down his fans. but hey.. look at me, i am a fan. not a crazy one.. I don't live for his music. i will not die if i don't listen to his music. i am just an average listener who likes his music and hence I am here. This group is everyone. including you.. but just like it is your right to express what you feel.. and what you feel seems a lot like a personal vendetta against AR, i feel it is my right to express what i feel about you. this group is indeed useless for you. because this ain't no whiners' forum. Hoping the scenario changes soon. Hoping that you would leave right now! Regards, Ranjit Am I being harsh enough ? sorry. had to let it out. --- On Sat, 17/7/10, Madhavan Rajan <rsamadhu2002@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Madhavan Rajan <rsamadhu2002@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [arr] Lost Touch due to Tours and Live Programms To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Saturday, 17 July, 2010, 9:59 AM Please stay away from AR's music...****I know all ARR fans will agree with my request**** On Thu, Jul 15, 2010 at 10:12 AM, Naveen B <arrma...@yahoo. com> wrote: Hi all, I m a great fan of ARR. Since arr got oscar, he has lost his touch and creativity due to no rest and live programms. Listen to all his songs after OSCAR, no touch of ARR. May be all done by his KM students. We need ARR of those roja and boys days. Its a kind request to ARR bhai, please avoid Tours and Live shows. when a Mani ratnam and Shanker audio going to release we had an expectation, because ARR had overcomed that expectation, but now no expectation. See in the case of Ravan, what an expectation, Songs average no picturisation for songs in a Mani Film ;( Also Puli (Worst songs) all repetative Power star -> New+aah+blue Ammathale -> enna enna song from Udhaya Doche -> Spiderman song from New Namakame -> Oh palanhare+Ek tu hi barosa Please Sir give dates to new directors in Tamil, Please do less Hindi Films. I know all ARR fans will agree with my request Thanks and regards True ARR Fan Naveen Pillai Dubai UAE -- Cheers, Madhavan.R Be a Music Fan; not a Music Pirate! -- ------------ --------- --------- ----- http://roshanravi. com http://ramblingsoul .com http://cssheaven. org
