One has to understand that Endiran isn't a movie like Hollywood sci-fi movies. Its done with Indian audience perspective in mind. Do you think calling Endhiran music as music for kids is anything less than glorified bashing? What is your opinion for a person who wrote a review which was worst than ever. Now lets come to the point when somebody writes a harsh review on music and calls it as his expression of opinion and then gets harsh feedback as "opinion" on his writing? why does somebody have to take the shelter of claiming no rights for expression? The person who writes the opinion should be ready to take opinion of others when expressed. Why does the reviewer not like the review for his writing or cant welcome, why should that he consider that as a criticism? And coming to Hollywood scores I can still listen to the older sound formats even by the legendary composers for Sci-Fi sometimes I hear repeated sound itself. And as a person working in music we are required to do this because we have to make people imagine the scene with the obvious sound. If I am given a liberty to score what ever I want I just cant use elephant trumpet kind of sound or Goat sound for the scene where a Robot walks and mix it in the name of creativity & experimentation no matter how influential as a composer or arranger one would have been. I dont remember any songs for Robot / Sci-fi movie done by Hollywood artists for a movie score unless its an independent sound track done by various artists and then included as original soundtrack. The case of Endhiran unfortunately isn't the one like how Sci-Fi movies are done in Hollywood. Here songs are the part of the movie and the supposed Robot is Rajni. Its easy to write opinion because the one who does that would never have experienced the pain and never would have undergone the limitation, influence, pressure of what its felt to deliver the product. Always remember an artist is also a human like us, paying a petty amount for the movie or for its sound track doesn't authorize us to treat them like servants. We who have "bash"ed the opinions have never bashed the opinion but the way it was expressed. And every mail from such bashers says the same thing. We dont bother whether one likes or dislikes the song, instead we write when somebody has used derogatory expressions. I dont wish to argue more.
--- In [email protected], kishore parayath <kishore.paray...@...> wrote: > > No one is bashing here! Everyone has the freedom to express his views. > Infact, it is the community members who are 'bashing' some people here, who > express their honest views. > > And regarding the music required for a sci-fi subject. Please refer the > scores of sci-fi movies produced in Hollywood. Then U would understand what > is required for such a subject. And we all know, that ARR is capable of > doing much more than many of those Hollywood composers. > > Iam enjoying the sounds in Endhiran and the layering in Arima Arima. Also, I > like Endhiran more than Sivaji... Juz because, Endhiran has the sounds which > I expected in Sivaji. Very enjoyable. But certainly the concepts and genres > are very old (Unusually from ARR). We would love ARR trying such genres... > But we dont want ARR to follow the textbook format.. We want him in the > Rahmantic way.. Always like a mad musical scientist like how CHORD qoutes > many times. > Remember when ARR experimented with jazz in Iruvar?? Did he ever follow the > style, established by the legends of Jazz back in the 70's and 80's ?? No.. > He went into mad experimentation giving masterpieces like vennilaa vennillaa > which would even leave the jazz legends awestruck;and also resulting in > some hybrid tracks like 'Aayirathil Naan Oruvan' and 'Kannai Katti', > where *'Dave > Brubeck met MS Vishwanathan'*. > > On Wed, Aug 4, 2010 at 10:24 PM, yeshrao81 <yeshra...@...> wrote: > > > > > > > Lot of you are complaining Endhiran is childish, depressing, repetitive in > > sound,not even a single memorable tune blah blah blah... > > > > Guys common give it a thought...What type of score would you expect for a > > sci-fi? It is very apt and once the movie releases, this would be sounding > > great with the visuals... > > > > Besides this, also note that every human has creative limitations....ARR > > cannot be endlessly creative in giving master pieces like Dilse or Taal at > > every attempt...arent we demanding soooo much...? > > > > To me even if I see the last 3 albums - VTV, Raavan, Endhiran...each and > > every song was unique....How can the same man giving us Aromale to Khili Re > > to Pudhiya Manidha to Hosanna to Behne De to Irumbile. To me this is > > mindblowing creativity... Man still does he not satisfy you with all your > > musical needs? > > > > All I am asking is, have some thought before you write something negative > > on ARR...imagine the stress ARRs mind must be undergoing to create one tune > > after the other and make it match the movie script, satisfy the mass fans, > > satisfy the super star, satisfy the critics and above all satisfy all of > > us...the fan group...Just have some nice words when blaming his music > > without abruptly thrashing something...We got to respect his creativity > > after all!!! > > > > > > >
