|
>then how come you have continued to contradict what they have written
about Assam's discontents?
Which part I contradicted, or you
think I contradicted?
I think it is your damn
English.
RB
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, January 23, 2006 9:30
PM
Subject: Re: [Assam] GREEN GOLD: THE
EMPIRE OF TEA
Hi Rajen:
I read the article. Left me completely confounded.
>I think MacFarlanes are
great. they have expressed the whole thing so succinctly.
*** This is the MOST CONTRADICTORY statement I have seen in recent years
from you in Assam Net. If you think the McFarlanes are GREAT, then how come
you have continued to contradict what they have written about Assam's
discontents?
Is it a problem with that damned English language? Or is it your
unenviable need to have it both ways?
I would like to think it is the former. That would be honorable.
Take care.
c
At 1:41 PM -0600 1/23/06, Rajen Barua wrote:
Umesh:
Thanks, you liked it.
I
think MacFarlanes are great. they have expressed the whole thing so
succinctly.
There was an error in my writing. The word 'hundreds' in the
following sentence should in fact read 'thousands'.
"Over the last two hundreds years this humble camellia tree
has grown into one of the most powerful social and economic forces known to
man."
Please note that the following sentence is my
addition:
"And that is how Assam lost its entrepreneurial
spirit."
RB
----- Original Message -----
From: umesh
sharma
To: Barua25 ;
[email protected]
Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Monday, January 23, 2006 12:35 PM
Subject: Re: [Assam] GREEN GOLD: THE EMPIRE OF
TEA
Thats a great book review. The skills of Maniram Dewan need to
developed again --now at a global level.
Umesh
"In 1839 the way was clear to rent the whole of Assam to the
highest bidder, and one came forward, calling itself The Assam Company,
a group of merchants formed in Great Winchester street in London. The
people of Assam were not allowed to take part. The British learned a great
bit about tea garden economy from wealthy Assamese entrepreneur like
Maniram Dewan. However when his service was no longer required, he
was isolated. Later he was hanged in a hastily conducted court on charge
of treason during the Sepoy Mutiny on 1857. And that is how Assam
lost its entrepreneurial spirit."
Barua25 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
wrote:
Book
review
GREEN GOLD: THE
EMPIRE OF TEA
by- Alan & Iris
MacFarlane.
Published
2004
Overbrook Press,
Woodstock, NY 12498
A MUST READ
AND MUST KEEP FOR ALL ASSAMESE:
At last a book on
tea, which describes the whole story with all the fascination and
romance of the tea plant, and the industry it developed and much more.
"Tea is more than just a drink. Over the last two hundreds years this
humble camellia tree has grown into one of the most powerful social and
economic forces known to man." Thus starts MacFarlan'e book "Green
Gold, The Empire of Tea." Tea was very popular in China and
gradually, "a huge trade in bricks of tea grew along the Silk Road cris
crossing from southwest China to Siberia and as far as the Islamic
civilizations of the Middle East." By the twelfth century in fact tea
bricks were being used as one popular currency in China in trade. By the
fifteenth century tea drinking has influenced a greater part of the
world. "The records of the use of tea suggest that it first arrived in
Amsterdam in 1610, in France in 1630s and England in
1657."
No one really knows where
exactly the tea originated. Although China is thought to be the place or
origin, modern studies show that the tea plant actually originated in
the foothills of eastern Himalayas, around Assam, some sixty to hundred
thousand years ago.The story of
modern tea industry itself is fascinating, and it practically started
with the discovery of wild tea plant, Camellia Sinensis var Camellia
Assamica, in the beautiful state of Assam, India in early
nineteenth century. Since then the tea industry has contributed to
the wealth and economy of many nations. Most importantly, it has
contributed to the growth of the British Empire itself. But these growth
in wealth and economy of nations were achieved at what cost? Tea
Industry had its mixed affect on the native people of Assam who were
exposed to the benefits of the western culture on one hand but on the
other hand they lost their most valuable thing, their political
independence because of it. In fact, the growth of the modern tea
industry is intricately intertwined with the history and culture of the
Assamese people during the British colonialism in the nineteenth
century. To understand this sensitive story, one will have to live in
Assam and while trying to understand the tea industry must also try to
understand the Assamese society from inside. And that is what Mrs.
MacFarlane and her son, the co-authors of the book did. Mrs. Iris
MacFarlane was an widow a tea planter in Assam, and while
spending their lives in tea gardens in Assam, they have encountered the
Assamese culture closely.
MacFarlanes reflect
that sad historyof Assam, "On March 13, 1824 the British marched slowly
up from Calcutta, guns mounted on elephants, to take Assam.... The newly
appointed Commissioner David Scott was reassuring, 'We are not forced
into your country by the thirst of conquest, but are forced in our
defense..'...And that was the beginning of how Assam lost its
independence. The British were good administrators, and they took it
upon themselves to replace the old style tax collection system of Assam
by their own. The relaxed Ahom methods of tax collection in
service or produce was replaced by an army of revenue farmers tramping
the country bearing demand papers totally incomprehensible to the
illiterate peasantry
The Marwaries, the merchant moneylenders of
Rajasthan saw their chance to fish in troubled waters
.The situation was
such that Maniram Dewan one of the few rich entrepreneur of Assam had to
describe the situation as living in the belly of a tiger. He was
one who first supported the British but later was so disillusioned when
he found himself being excluded from generous land deals offered to the
Europeans. The British it seems wanted to have and eat the cake at the
same time. The British declared that nobody owned the forest which they
declared wasteland, and which they were prepared to rent out at very low
rates, but only in blocks of a hundred acres. No Assamese peasants could
take up their generous offers.
The puppet king Purandar Singha never
had a chance. When tea plant was discovered the British found that they
had given him the wrong bit of the country, the region where tea
grew. The rest is history. Shrewd administrator as they were, the
British took the Upper Assam from king Purandar Singha because he
defaulted in paying the annual tribute of Rs 50000 equivalent to US$
1000.. And that is how Assam lost its political independence
forever. However that is not all.
MacFarlanes
write, "The people of Assam were not consulted and it might seem strange
that none of them objected to the selling of their country to
foreigners, to seeing their forests disappear under thousands of acres
of spiky green tea bushes, the profits of which went to Calcutta and
London. .... They had to do that because as MacFarlane put it, "The
strength of the Assamese was also their weakness when it came to putting
up resistance to the newly arrived rulers. Unlike the rest of Indians,
they had no strong caste allegiances: ..There were no outcastes, no
women in purdah, there was no mechanism for corporate bargaining or
setting up solid resistance to what was happening. Relatively crime
free, caste free, self sufficient in basics of life, the Assamese saw
themselves being pushed aside as Europeans, Bengalis, Marwaris, Sikhs
poured in . There was little they could do, but for doing that little
they were always described as spineless and lazy. From the
administration point of view this was fine, from the tea planter's point
of view this was irritating."
In 1839 the way
was clear to rent the whole of Assam to the highest bidder, and one came
forward, calling itself The Assam Company, a group of merchants formed
in Great Winchester street in London. The people of Assam were not
allowed to take part. The British learned a great bit about tea garden
economy from wealthy Assamese entrepreneur like Maniram Dewan. However
when his service was no longer required, he was isolated. Later he
was hanged in a hastily conducted court on charge of treason during the
Sepoy Mutiny on 1857. And that is how Assam lost its
entrepreneurial spirit.
Since those days of
Sepoy Mutiny the tea industry and Assam itself have come a long way. The
British colonialism was over when India won independence in 1947, and
Assam joined India as one of its states. Today Assam produces about 20%
of world tea. However its problems of cultural subjugation and economic
deprivation are not over. "The gap between the high life and huge
profits of the British and the squalor and the misery of the laborers
was most obscene in the nineteenth century." However even after India's
independence, things actually have not improved much in favor of Assam.
So much so that "in April 1979, a few young Assamese youths met in the
ruined palace of the Ahom kings to talk of a free Assam for the benefits
of its people." And that was how United Liberation Front of Assam (ULFA)
was born. After a prolonged struggle against the mighty Indian army,
ULFA today seem to be slowly melting away. However they still remain in
the state as a strong insurgent group sometime running a parallel
government in those unruly parts of the North East
India.
MacFarlanes
conclude, "Tea has been an enormous boon for many countries in the
world. It should not be beyond the wit of richer nations and India
herself, to ensure that a fairer amount of profits made from it, as well
as from oil and gas, be returned to the people who work in Assam. ...Yet
fair trade, with profits with profits going to the producers, should be
examined closely in relation to this plantation commodity. ...It would
only seem fair that some of the wealth generated by green gold, which
has hitherto flowed elsewhere, should help the people of
Assam."
The book also has various other interesting aspects and
historical notes of the tea industry. It is gratifying and meaningful to
note that MacFarlanes have donated the book . I would recommend this
book to anyone who wants to know the whole story of modern tea industry
and its affect in the land where it started, Assam. I recommend
that every Assamese read and keep a copy of the book in their
home.
Rajen Barua,
Houston
20th Jan
2006
Note: A summary of the review
is available in Amazon.Com
RB
.
_______________________________________________ assam
mailing
list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
Umesh Sharma 5121 Lackawanna ST College Park, MD
20740
1-202-215-4328 [Cell Phone]
Ed.M. - International
Education Policy Harvard Graduate School of Education, Harvard
University, Class of 2005
How much mail storage do you get for
free? Yahoo! Mail gives you 1GB! Get
Yahoo! Mail
_______________________________________________ assam
mailing
list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
|