Thanks Saurav for a highly illuminating and intellectually stimulating
analysis.










At 9:24 PM -0500 1/24/06, SP wrote:
>dear himendra-da,
>
>i read with interest your article on atan burhagohain sako.
>though it is well written, and quite illuminating in parts,
>i think you have muddled up some general issues.
>
>for example, you seem to suggest that the attack by the
>mughals was an attack from someone alien to india because
>they were muslims, and that the participation of ram singh
>in saraighat was an abberation, promptly corrected by ram
>singh's mother.  i find this view amusing because a clean
>hindu-muslim dichotomy of medieval india is not possible.
>
>the commander of the mughal forces in saraighat, ram singh, was
>the son of mirza raja jai singh, who defeated shivaji after
>the maratha tiger had badly mauled shaistha khan.  the cunning
>jai singh, a hindu, succeeded in running shivaji down and
>presenting him at aurangzeb's court.  though shivaji is the symbol
>of hinduism to many, yet he employed muslim troops in his army.
>
>soon after the death of the illustrious jai singh his son
>ram singh was made the king and his first assignment was assam.
>like you, i too would be interested in reading the letter he
>received from his mother, to find out how the widow of a valorous
>rajput counselled her son on his first but failing campaign.
>
>i will forego some of the heroic acts by muslims (eg bagh hazarika)
>at saraighat for lachit borphukan, because they are well known.
>about a decade earlier, mir jhumla's chroniclers damned the
>muslims settled in assam because they were "more assamese than
>muslims".  in medieval india, just as we find hindus fighting
>against hindus for their muslim masters, we find muslims
>fighting against muslims for their hindu masters too, as in
>the case of shivaji.
>
>anyway, ram singh went back to being a noble in aurangzeb's court.
>when aurangzeb's son muhammed akbar rebelled against his father
>and tried to form an alliance with the rajputs and the marathas,
>ram singh was one of the many hindu kings who went in pursuit.
>akbar failed in getting help from those who you probably consider
>"natives" and finally left for persia where he died.  one of the
>descendents of the "alien" aurangzeb wrote in rangoon pinning for
>his country:
>
>hai kitana badanasiib zafar dafn ke liye
>do gaz zamiin bhii na milii kU-e-yaar me.n
>
>medieval india was neither hindu nor muslim.  it was a composite
>entity, culturally and politically.  there were tensions between the
>hindus and muslims, undoubtedly.  as there were tensions between
>different castes and other socials formations. 
>
>if you are looking for either ideological or religious purity
>in history, you will be disappointed.  the assamese did not have to
>fear the second attack of ram singh and thank his mother for taking
>him away.  lachit's own brother and successor, laluk sola borphukan,
>gifted away a hard earned guwahati to the mughals within a few years
>of saraighat, during the time of aurangzeb itself, and left for
>gargaon to try and become a king himself.
>
>lest we forget, the only lesson history teaches us consistently
>is irony.
>
>--
>saurav
>
>_______________________________________________
>assam mailing list
>[email protected]
>http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org

_______________________________________________
assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org

Reply via email to