At 10:03 AM -0800 1/24/06, Rajib Das wrote:
>As usual, you have skirted the main issue


*** Heh-heh! Isn't that the truth?


>  >So let's attempt to focus on what we started off
>discussing, shall we?


*** You sir are the one who needs the focusing. May I suggest you 
sleep on the matter and see if you can figure it out on your own? I 
would expect you to be able to that. But should you fail, we will 
talk it over in class someitme tomorrow :-).











>  about this
>discussion. We all know the usual views you hold and I
>hold. So let's attempt to focus on what we started off
>discussing, shall we?
>
>Let me reiterate.
>
>1. You said India listens to violence. And I said no,
>it does not, so long as it does not hurt India bad
>enough.
>
>2. I also said ULFA does not have the capability to
>hurt India bad enough to bring it to its knees.
>
>3. The only people hurting with all this violence
>therefore are the people of Assam. The ULFA does have
>the capability to render Assam unstable and hurt the
>people real bad and that, it has proven.
>
>This is essentially what we are arguing.
>
>Let's forget for a moment about 'poitrik xompotti',
>GOI intentions, ULFA's intentions, God's intentions,
>Hindu intentions etc. etc. And let's fall back on
>reality to say yay or nay on these points alone.
>
>By the way, as a footnote, here is a question: Is it
>ULFA's 'poitrik xompotti' that it extorts hard earned
>money from defenceless civilians at gun point?
>
>
>
>>  >  >"But I guess some
>>  >folks are slow learners, if at all learners."
>>
>>
>>  *** And I stand by my assessment and rest my case.
>>
>
>
>--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
>>  That is deep!
>>
>>  >First off, India does not pay heed to violence.
>>
>>  Heh, heh! Tell it to the judge!
>>
>>
>>  >  >You
>>  >can go do as much violence as you want and the
>>  federal
>>  >Indian government will not budge on core issues.
>>
>>
>>  *** Yeah, sure! Real estate is more important than
>>  people. But we
>>  knew that . It runs in Hindu veins!
>>
>>
>>  >  The ULFA has been reduced to, at best, a feeble
>>  force.
>>
>>  *** So resort to taunting, when the going gets
>>  rough!
>>
>>
>>  >  >Its violence is
>>  >limited to keeping Assam unstable - blowing up
>>  >pipelines here and there, doing extortion on
>>  >defenceless civilians and doing a few bomb blasts
>>  >every Republic day.
>>
>>  *** Just so Indian colonialists could hold on to its
>>  'poitrik xompotti'
>>  ( ancestral property) of the real estate of Assam,
>>  to hell with the
>>  lives of people! Just like in Kashmir.
>>
>>
>>  >India can contain this violence till eternity.
>>
>>  *** Contain? That damned English language problem
>>  again isn't it? It
>>  is CONTAINING it?  How about NOT GIVING a damn about
>>  what happens to
>>  the people of Assam, as long as India's control of
>>  Assam's land and
>>  its resources are preserved?
>>
>>
>>
>>  >  >Unless ULFA is able
>>  >to ratchet up the violence big time in a short
>>  duration, i
>>
>>
>>  *** Isn't that noble? Taunt ULFA to RATCHET up the
>>  violence?  Surely
>>  shows the intellectual depth of the taunter here.
>>
>>
>>
>>  >  >As a result, one needs to understand the real
>>  gains
>>  >versus the real losses you get from this violence.
>>
>>
>>  *** As in maintain the status quo, NOT give in to
>>  Assam's discontent
>>  and make peace? With friends like that Assam hardly
>>  needs enemies.
>>
>>
>>
>>  >  >"But I guess some
>>  >folks are slow learners, if at all learners."
>>
>>
>>  *** And I stand by my assessment and rest my case.
>>
>>
>>
>>  cm
>>
>>
>>  At 5:54 PM -0800 1/23/06, Rajib Das wrote:
>>  >And therein lies the detachment from reality.
>>  >
>>  >First off, India does not pay heed to violence. You
>>  >can go do as much violence as you want and the
>>  federal
>>  >Indian government will not budge on core issues.
>>  Not
>>  >unless it is in danger of breaking up. And it isn't
>>  >breaking up any time soon - even in the detractors'
>>  >dreams.
>>  >
>>  >Secondly the level of violence. The ULFA has been
>>  >reduced to, at best, a feeble force. Its violence
>>  is
>>  >limited to keeping Assam unstable - blowing up
>  > >pipelines here and there, doing extortion on
>>  >defenceless civilians and doing a few bomb blasts
>>  >every Republic day. India can contain this violence
>>  >till eternity. All ULFA's violence is capable of at
>>  >this point is keeping the state unstable and
>>  denying
>>  >the people of Assam a stable environment to go
>>  develop
>>  >productive lives for themselves. Unless ULFA is
>>  able
>>  >to ratchet up the violence big time in a short
>>  >duration, it's prospects are as bad as trying to
>>  >expect humongous growth in baby products in the
>>  >Japanese market.
>>  >
>>  >As a result, one needs to understand the real gains
>>  >versus the real losses you get from this violence.
>>  Any
>>  >which way you do the math, the people of Assam are
>>  way
>>  >worse off than if we had this violence.
>>  >
>>  >Unfortunately, to use C-da's words, "But I guess
>>  some
>>  >folks are slow learners, if at all learners."
>>  >
>>  >
>>  >--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>>  >
>>  >>  >Its for us to read between the lines :)
>>  >>
>>  >>  *** Yes, indeed.
>>  >>
>>  >>
>>  >>  And when *I* do that, I never cease to  ANNOY,
>>  even
>>  >>  upset, so many of
>>  >>  our good friends to all heck, eliciting scathing
>>  >>  criticisms, not to
>>  >>  mention aspersions to be cast on my motives and
>>  >>  judgements on my
>>  >>  character and attitudes :-)!
>>  >>
>>  >>
>>  >>  >You think its the 'VIOLENCE' gets Delhi's
>>  >>  attention.
>>  >>
>>  >>  *** I don't just think so, Ram -- I believe so.
>>  It
>>  >>  is much too
>>  >>  obvious from decades of what has been going on
>>  >>  across the length and
>>  >>  breadth of ALL of India, to believe otherwise.
>>  But I
>>  >>  also know that
>>  >>  the power of self-suggestion is very strong.
>>  Many a
>>  >>  fine Indian lulls
>>  >>  oneself to a torpor, unable to see what stares
>>  one
>>  >>  in the face.
>>  >>
>>  >>
>>  >>  >In that case, the ULFA should go all out on a
>>  >>  rampage - they may
>>  >>  >even realize >the dream, don't you think? That
>>  will
>>  >>  teach Delhi a
>>  >>  >lesson, right.
>>  >>
>>  >>  *** Ram, it is this kind of reasoning, from
>>  >  > otherwise able
>>  >>  people,that elicits verbal-mayhem in Assam Net
>>  :-).
>>  >>  Just like GoI
>>  >>  actions and inaction have spawned the numerous
>>  >>  insurgencies and
>>  >>  rebellions ever since independence.
>>  >>
>>  >>
>>  >>  >So, now that the date has been announced, the
>>  ULFA
>>  >>  will presumbly
>>  >>  >cease and >desist, right?
>>  >>
>>  >>  *** I can't read ULFA's mind and they don't ask
>>  for
>>  >>  my advice or
>>  >>  consent. But if I were to be in their shoes,in a
>>  >>  grossly asymmetrical
>>  >>  warfare with an overwhelmingly more powerful
>>  >>  adversary, I certainly
>>  >>  won't let their detractors know what to expect
>>  next.
>>  >>  Would you?
>>  >>  Pre-determined, cause and effect responses with
>>  >>  predictable stances
>>  >>  these could not be.
>>  >>
>>  >>  One might have thought the decision makers at
>>  Delhi
>>
>=== message truncated ===
>
>
>__________________________________________________
>Do You Yahoo!?
>Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
>http://mail.yahoo.com

_______________________________________________
assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org

Reply via email to