Thanks Saurav for another immensely informative, educational and 
thoughtful piece. For a historically challenged person like myself, 
it was extremely illuminating.










At 2:49 PM -0500 1/28/06, SP wrote:
>dear himendra-da,
>
>
>Himendra Thakur said on AssamNet:
>
>
>+  Dear Saurav,
>+ 
>+  I never mentioned that the attack in Saraighat was made by Muslims. Please
>+  check it out carefully. Please also find out why you missed this very vital
>+  point.
>+ 
>+  I was very definite to point out that the attack was made by Invaders . the
>+  same invaders who attacked India in 1193 (& again in 1526.) These were
>+  Islamic invaders from outside India. Nothing is "muddled up" in this
>+  statement.
>+ 
>
>though you assert you mentioned invaders and not muslims, the rest of
>your post was fixated on muslims.  you seem to be pointing at the muslims
>not by name but by implication.  and believe me, the implication is very
>transparent.
>
>still, "invader" too has serious problems.  the muslims came to be
>called yavana, but the word was originally used for the greeks and
>the scythians (origin: ionia).  the rajputs and other militant groups
>in northwest india are descendents of the scythians (sakas), and they
>too were invaders at some point and were called yavanas. 
>
>btw, "thakur" comes from the scythian subgroup thukarian!!
>
>atan burhagohain, in whose name you want to build a xako, was a descendent
>of "invaders" who came in 1228.  just as aurangzeb was a descendent of
>"invaders" who came in 1526.
>
>
>+  After the 1193 attack, the invaders, having the advantage of excellent
>+  cavalry equipped with Arab horses, spread over the Indo-Gangetic 
>plains at a
>+  very high speed. Defeating all local rulers, they arrived in Bihar by 1200
>+  AD (about 1400 miles in 7 years, @ 200 miles per year) and, after beheading
>+  the Buddhist scholars, they burnt down Nalanda University. They proceeded
>+  further to the East. They occupied Bengal in 1205. They were stopped in
>+  Assam.  These are historical records.
>
>
>invasions are common occurances in historical times and are legitimate
>steps in new nation building.  they do not negate legitimacy.  the most
>beautiful example is assam. 
>
>
>+  Under the early Islamic rule, a new custom, called Jawhar-Vrata, 
>got started
>+  in the Indo-Gangetic plains: groups of Hindu women would jump 
>into a bonfire
>+  to evade molestation. The historical record of Jawhar Vrata ( not 
>present in
>+  pre-Islamic India) proves the degree of atrocity by the Islamic invaders.
>+ 
>
>jauhar is a custom and ritual found exclusively in the desert regions of
>rajasthan and not in the indo-gangetic plains.  the most celebrated incident
>involved the rajput queen padmini.  but that tells only half the story.
>in the 13th century a rajput army cornered by turks decided to
>immolate all those who could not fight, women, children and the infirm,
>ground to dust the diamonds in their possession, melt the gold and silver,
>destroy all provisions and then go out to battle and die.
>
>as a military strategy, there is a term for this---scorched earth policy.
>it worked wonders, especially in the desert, where invading armies
>depended heavily on captured provisions and treasure to sustain themselves
>in the short term and make profit in the long run.  that this strategy
>worked in the desert regions is no surprise, which further explains why
>the custom did not become popular elsewhere.
>
>before you make it into a hindu-muslim issue, take into consideration
>the facts that jauhar had a military origin, that it was geographically
>localized mainly to the desert regions, that it was identified with just
>one varna (kshatriya) and that too an ethnic subsection of it (rajputs)
>and that women did not have a large say in it---some were forcibly
>immolated and even killed by the sword.
>
>
>+  What I wrote above are historical facts. I am now going make an assumption
>+  that, under the early Islamic rule in Indo-Gangetic plains, if a Hindu
>+  family had five brothers, two would convert to Islam to protect the
>+  remaining three. That was how the Indian Muslims started. They 
>protected the
>+  Hindus on one hand, and cooled down the ruthlessness of the Invaders on the
>+  other hand.
>+ 
>+  The above assumption is based on the fact that, unlike Persia, land of
>+  Zoroastrian population, which became completely Islamized, Hindus survived
>+  in India, thanks to their Muslim brothers. Another historical fact is that,
>+  in the later years, the Invaders softened to a great extent.
>+ 
>+  However, the Hindus could survive under Islamic Rule only by playing a
>+  double standard: one opinion inside the house, and a very different opinion
>+  outside. Another  survival skill was the capacity to change the 
>meaning of a
>+  spoken word: if a Hindu said something against the Sultan and was 
>challenged
>+  by a Sultan's katwal, the Hindu must be able to change the meaning of what
>+  he said, just to save his neck. Running for several centuries, these habits
>+  have become second-nature of the people of the Indo-Gangetic plains, which
>+  can be observed even today.  Hindus were definitely living a life of
>+  second-class citizen under Islamic rule. No wonder such a situation gave
>+  rise to quislings and petains and pierre lavals who prospered by exploiting
>+  their fellow countrymen.
>
>
>that your view on medieval india is based on a hindu-muslim dichotomy
>is best exemplified in the three paragraphs above.  they are imaginary
>and fantastic to say the least.
>
>
>+  My great anxiety is the danger that Assamese people are facing due to the
>+  huge number of Bangladeshi infiltrators. The anxiety is based on
>+  geopolitical forces. My great fear is that the landmass of Assam 
>will become
>+  like Kashmir or Chittagong Hill District. My great fear is that Assamese
>+  people will become like Kashmiri refugees now living in the 
>streets of Delhi
>+  or Lucknow, or Chakma refugees who are being driven out from 
>place to place.
>
>your characterization of the threat to the assamese people was the main
>reason for this and the previous post.  so here is my brief take on
>it.
>
>the kashmir problem is more than the hindu-muslim problem that you
>make it out to be.  i don't want to recount well known history---sheikh
>abdullah's stand on pakistan and national conference's rejection of
>the muslim league's proposal.  the latest problems stem from the
>insurgency in the 80's, a relatively recent manifestation of a much
>older problem.
>
>your assam-kashmir analogy is ridiculous and banks too much on
>hindu-muslim dichotomy and scare tactics.  in assam, the issue of
>influx is a case of economic migration, not a question of nationalism. 
>or religion.  you could drive it to a religious conflict, of course. 
>but for now, it is not yet a religious problem .  the problem for
>the assamese people come from a variety of other sources.
>
>foremost among them is the inability of the assamese to solve the
>inter-ethnic conflicts in the region.  historically, those who claimed
>to speak for the assamese have neither convinced anyone that their
>problems are problems for the ethnic groups too, nor have they
>accepted the problems faced by ethnic groups as their own.  even today,
>as the ethnic conflicts are increasing, the assamese are largely silent
>and seem to have no opinion.  a friend of mine visited a bodo refugee
>camp near bongaigaon recently.  a bodo refugee camp!!  the bodos are one
>of the most ancient settlers in that land---one of the autochthones
>if you will---and they are in refugee camps, surviving on government
>handouts!!  the karbis too are in refugee camps.  and as they spend
>time in refugee camps, the lands which they had occupied, or which
>their children would have occupied, lie fallow for others to come
>in and set up a vegetable patch.  the failure of the assamese to
>form alliances, and reduce conflict within ethnic groups is creating
>problems for itself in general and is also influencing the influx in
>an indirect way.
>
>the assamese are facing new challenges from the media.  assamese and
>other local languages have a minimal presence on tv.  their presence on
>computers and the internet is almost zilch.  new technology provide new
>challenges to cultures.  assam is doing well in commercializing the
>theater (bhramyomaan) but doing badly in film.  there have been other
>challenges in the past.  just when urbanization had started, the assamese
>succeeded in transforming a pastoral/agrarian festival (the bihu) into
>an urban celebration.  as a result, bihu is a festival celebrated today
>not just by the upstream assamese, or some ethnic groups, but by others
>as well.  today, pithas and larus, the traditional snacks---so laboriously
>made in the past by assamese women at night according to tradition---are
>available in the marketplace.  many people today, who did not traditionally
>make pithas, now serve them at home during bihu.  commercialization will
>dilute "ownership" issues and let people share cultural artifacts---in
>the face of opposition from the purists.
>
>so i would put down the bigger challenges to the assamese today as---the
>ethnic conundrum, the hurdle of new media and commercialization of
>cultural artifacts.
>
>to fixate on the muslim influx, otoh, is ridiculous.  first it is a
>distraction.  from the beginning of the assam movement in 1979 till
>today---a period of thirty years---the challenges have come not from the
>influx, but from elsewhere.  second, to take on a large population (assam
>has the highest percent muslim population after kashmir) and be in perpetual
>conflict with it is adding to the problem, not solving it.   the influx itself
>is a complex issue that needs to be tackled sensitively.  to reduce
>it to a rhetoric would be cynical at best. 
>
>
>+  To fight this battle, I was urging my countrymen to draw strength from
>+  Saraighat and build a memorial to Atan Buragohain which will 
>inspire people.
>+  That was the main purpose of the article that you are criticizing. It is
>+  very sad that you did not even mention about the ATAN BURAGOHAIN SAKO : A
>+  Bridge Across Three Centuries.
>
>
>well, tell me---how much does the statue of lachit at saraighat 
>inspire people?
>the image of lachit is now being used to gather hindu votes.  is that what
>you mean by inspire?  
>
>saurav
>
>_______________________________________________
>assam mailing list
>[email protected]
>http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org

_______________________________________________
assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org

Reply via email to