Saurav: 

Thanks for explaining. But based on what I know of you, I am not quite sure 
that personal sentiments are the only reason why YOU care about these issues. I 
may be wrong - but you probably see a future social value to conservation.  

You see, I wrote about this because I see it as a vexing problem. 

The current generation values certain attributes and wants to conserve it for 
the benefit of future generations. But the preferences of the future 
generations may be very different and are partly determined by how the current 
generation influences social change.

Take the case of the natural environment. The case for conserving the natural 
environment is the value it will yield to future generations. Because we know 
they will value it. To not conserve, would hurt them (based on all current 
conception of what they and their world will be like). 

If you want to extend the same argument to cultural attributes (including 
language, religion etc) - it gets a bit dicey. It is qite possible and likely 
that a future generation may assign no value (apart from historical curiosity) 
to such objects. So when we ask for conservation, we also implicitly ask that 
social change ought to occur in such a way that the future generations will 
actually value what we want to conserve - in some sense, they should be 
somewhat like us. This is a much more difficult proposition. 

If we believe, the future generation will not care about laru pitha, then it is 
rational for us to actually not impart the skill of making laru pithas to our 
progenies. But because we do not teach our progenies how to make laru pitha or 
to value them, they will not value it. Thus, the disappearance of laru pitha 
becomes a self-fulilling conjecture. 

On the other hand, if we collectively modifed current society and not only 
taught our children to make laru pithas but also created the kind of social 
transition that allows the making and eating of laru pithas to flourish in the 
future, the value we place on conserving laru pithas fr the future could also 
be self-fulfilling. 

Is one self-fulfilling conjecture better than the other from a social point of 
view? I don't know.

All I know is that it is probably in this context, that one must understand the 
historical role of conservationists of socio-cultural attrbutes. 

Sorry, I am not being very articulate. More later. Take care -

Santanu-da. 

Santanu-da. 


-----Original Message-----
From: xourov pathok [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Sun 1/29/2006 2:44 PM
To: Roy, Santanu; [email protected]
Subject: RE: Threat to the assamese
 


"Roy, Santanu" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Saurav: 
I understand. But quite apart from the context in which this discussion arose - 
let us for a moment suppose that Bihu simply degenerates into a holiday - an 
excuse for urban young people to get drunk, play hindi music etc. In the 
extreme, lets suppose it simply disappears - no memory whatsover. For that 
matter lets suppose, all of the traditional festivals of all the people 
disappear. Would it imply that the people have lost themselves? Or that society 
has simply evolved that new festivals and new traditions grounded in the 
current social reality of the people have emerged. And in that changed reality, 
there will be a new perception of the people about their past that will allow 
them to alter the essence of what it means to be an Assamese. Hundred years 
from now, a new Xourav will be identifying threats to Assamese culture thar you 
- saurav - would consider to be sacrilege - will be fighting to defend a new 
language - that you might consider entirely alien today.
Santanu-da.  
 
 santanu-da,
 
 you know the answer to this as well as i do.  it would by no means imply that 
the people have lost themselves.  they would have have simply moved on.  and 
indeed a new xourov would be listing the new threats to assamese society!!
 
 but you should be able to differentiate between two aspects of the issue.  the 
objective reality---which is what i tried to portray, and the value of the of 
the cultural artifacts to me, personally.  they are two different things.  you 
know it, as well as i do.  in one you attach a personal value, in the other you 
don't.
 
 somehow, the personal value provides a momentum, to sustain it in one form or 
the other.  and as you mentioned in reply to utpal-da's mail, this is a natural 
tendency.
 
 saurav
 
 
 
 


                
---------------------------------
Bring words and photos together (easily) with
 PhotoMail  - it's free and works with Yahoo! Mail.


_______________________________________________
assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org

Reply via email to