>We should feel bad about it. Correction: We should NOT feel bad about it. The Chinese donot feel bad when they say that Buddhism is a foreign religion imported to China from India. So the Japanese. Barua
----- Original Message ----- From: "barua25" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "A Mailing list for people interested in Assam from around the world" <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, September 29, 2007 1:09 PM Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > America was founded by the Europeans. When they came they brought not only > the European languages but also the European religions and cultures. Thus > Christianity as well as Englsih and all other European languages are > brought from Europe which make the big Western culture now. Red Indian > culture has been wiped out for all practical purposes. Thus it is > irrelevant to say that English language and Christianity are foreign to > America. Because these were there from day one of American modern history. > In America it is the mother tongue of the huge majority population. It is > true that in America both Christianity as well as the English language had > undergone much change. It is often said that America and England are two > countries separated by one language. > > In case of India, it is a different ball game. The English people did not > establish the Indian culture. A foreign language, English, was given to > the Indians only about a hundred years ago. No Indians had any roots in > English language. The British left but the Indians stuck to their language > and many other English items (like Cricket, Democracy, our dress, > educational institutions, civic laws etc). It is true that we are trying > our best to Indianise the language so much so that it is often called > Hindlish and not English. Even now there is a strong section of Indians > who are opposed to Hindlish. (as well as the others). Even now English is > considered a foreign language by a strong section of the Indian > population. I would say in another hundred years probably Hindlish will > penetrate more to the Indian culture. But I donot think it will ever go > the Indian lower class; it will remain a middle class language of > communication. It is probably now 20/30% Indians who speak Hindlish. May > be in another hundred years, it will be 30/40% may be. But it will never > be the mother tongue of any sizable section of Indians. > > The very fact that you, Ram and others feel offended when I point out, > like a sizable section of Indians, that English is a foreign language > goes to prove how much we Indians depend on Hindlish, how we Indians love > Hindlish. Probably Ram and you are right. Probably, we can say of > Hindlish, like the game of Cricket, is an Indian item. But we should be > ready to admit that these are imported items given to us by the British. > We should feel bad about it. > > In fact one great quality of us the Indians, unlike the Chinese, is the > quality to absorb foreign things like sponge absorbs water. > In the ancient times also, we absorbed many foreign elements, like idol > worship, astrology etc. > Rajen Barua > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Krishnendu Chakraborty" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: <[email protected]> > Sent: Saturday, September 29, 2007 9:09 AM > Subject: [Assam] Book review : India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > Rajenda, going by your logic, English is a foreign > language in US too which was brought in by Europeans. > > That unlike India Native languages have been killed in > US is a different topic. > > > >>>>Opinions are never debatable! >>>>Facts are. > Thanks > Barua > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Ram Sarangapani > To: A Mailing list for people interested in Assam > from around the world > Sent: Friday, September 28, 2007 11:54 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : India After > Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > >BTW I am not looking for an response on this from > you. I think this is a waste of >time even to debate > on this issue. > > It truely is a colossal waste. Just to let you know, > I didn't say what I said just because I felt like it, > there were very valid reasons, and your "foreign" > comment only triggered it..... and nothing more. > This is a hot topic in India today. If you are > interested, you might want to look into the New York > Times articles from yesterday (Sept. 28th) and also > about Mulayam Singh Yadav and his comments. > > Anyway --- I have totally lost interest in the topic > by now. > > Thanks > > --Ram > > > > > > On 9/28/07, Rajen & Ajanta Barua <barua25 at > hotmail.com> wrote: > Ram: > If you insist to know my views: > English is a foreign language in India because: > 1) It is not rooted in India. > 2) There is nothing Indian about it except the > fact the middle class Indians use it to overcome the > difficulty of their too many languages. > 3) It was never a language in India during the > last 5000 years of India's history except during the > British colonial rule. > 4) We even cannot say that we have been using this > language for 100 years even by the middle class. > 5) It can be compared only to Persian language > which was also at one time imposed as a court language > in India during the Moghol rules and which is dead in > India now. > 6) Even today, even after 100 years, it is spoken > in India by only 1.5% of Indians (quoted from email > net - less than 1.5% of the population actually have > proficiency in it-KC.) > 7) Nobody in India, even the majority of middle > class Indians like you, would consider English as an > Indian language. > > and many more. > > Indians always need something 'foreign' to rule > themselves: > the Aryans, the Rajputs, the Afghans, the Moghuls, > the British, and now the English language. > BTW I am not looking for an response on this from > you. I think this is a waste of time even to debate on > this issue. > Thanks > Barua > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Ram Sarangapani > To: A Mailing list for people interested in > Assam from around the world > Sent: Friday, September 28, 2007 10:09 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : India After > Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > >We can start with a definition of the word > 'foreign' looking at a dictionary > > Why look into a dictionary? I think most of us > know what "foreign" and what "native" means? The > dictionary is not going to tell me anything different. > > > >and see if we can call 'English' a foreign > language or a native language. > > You were the one who claimed it is a "foreign > language". So, before we put this into a plebicite of > sorts, I wanted to know why you call it "foreign". > I said it is not a foreign language in India, > and I gave netters a few reasons. There are many more. > I hope you will provide us some reasons why you claim > it is foreign. > > Once you are able to do that, we can go from > there.:) > > --Ram > > > > > > > > > On 9/28/07, Rajen & Ajanta Barua <barua25 at > hotmail.com > wrote: > We can start with a definition of the word > 'foreign' looking at a dictionary and see if we can > call 'English' a foreign language or a native > language. > Next we can take the opinions of the general > Indian public in India whether general Indians think > English language is foreign or not.. > Those will be my two starting points. > What do you say? > Barua > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Ram Sarangapani > To: A Mailing list for people interested in > Assam from around the world > Sent: Friday, September 28, 2007 7:55 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : India > After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > Barua, > > I will let Alpana put forth her own defenses > :), and just to make it clear this is not a > husband-wife tag team ::) > > >Ram's weak defense as English not being a > foregn language also falls >pathetically into the same > catagory. > > Why do you think my defense is weak and can > you cite a few reasons why English is foreign, and we > will go from there. > > --Ram > > On 9/28/07, Rajen & Ajanta Barua <barua25 at > hotmail.com > wrote: > A/ > What you are trying to say is this: > "Although what you are saying seems to be > true, but I am not going to acknowledge it as truth, > because if I remember you said somthing in the past in > some other context which I did not like. As such > without checking your past words, I cannot acknowledge > it as truth although it may be a truth." > > In Indian culture we have been taught to > stand up for the truth irrespective of the speaker. > You aeem to be doing just the opposite. > It does not matter what I said in the past > in some other context. > A truth must acknolwedged as a truth. > Otherwise we will be always walking on > quick sands. > Ram's weak defense as English not being a > foregn language also falls pathetically into the same > catagory. > Barua > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Alpana B. Sarangapani > To: A Mailing list for people interested > in Assam from around the world > Sent: Friday, September 28, 2007 2:54 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : India > After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > > > >Can people just stand for the truth > without any qualm? > > Yes, they can. Absolutely! :) > > It is just that I remember your > suggesting that something was a justified cause for > Assam's asking for sovereignty, No? > > If you did, to remind you, it will take > me some time to dig into the emails again to find the > exact words though. > > In the mean time, please don't let that > bot.her you. > > Thank you. > - A. > > > > > > > "In order to make spiritual progress you > must be patient like a tree and humble like a blade of > grass" > > - Lakshmana > > > > > > > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------- > From: barua25 at hotmail.com > To: assam at assamnet.org > Date: Fri, 28 Sep 2007 14:22:58 -0500 > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : > India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > A/- > Why do you think I have any qualm at > all? > I am just statiung the facts for > people to acknowledge. > In the ancient India, it was also a > situational demand to learn Sanskrit to get into the > elite. Now it is English. > Is this a fact or not? > Can people just stand for the truth > without any qualm? > Barua > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Alpana B. Sarangapani > To: A Mailing list for people > interested in Assam from around the world > Sent: Friday, September 28, 2007 > 1:16 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : > India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > Hi Barua: > > I didn't quite understand. Your > qualm is against which - Hindi, English, or India's > being a united country. > > What do you suggest as a solution? > All states should balkanize and use their regional > language as the official language? Fine. > > What will be the official language > for Assam then? Assamese or Bodo or any other language > that are spoken in different parts of the state? Even > for Assamese, would it be the upper-Assamese or the > lower-Assamese version of it? > > Trust all is well with you all. > > Regards, > -Alpana > > > > > > > > > "In order to make spiritual progress > you must be patient like a tree and humble like a > blade of grass" > > - Lakshmana > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------------------------------ > Date: Thu, 27 Sep 2007 20:50:21 > -0700 > From: pseude at yahoo.com > To: assam at assamnet.org > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : > India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > First you said - "to get into the > elite, one must learn english". I gave you the example > of Laloo. There are many others like him. > > Next you said - "indian unity is > because of english". > > In India, more than 30% are native > speakers of Hindi and a total of between 65 and 75% > read, write and understand/speak the language. That > includes many southern speakers as well . > > Compare that to English - less > than 1.5% of the population actually have proficiency > in it. > > English is there not because it is > necessary to enforce unity but because it helps us get > business and do business with most of the outside > world. How you apply it is upto you. Remember I > mentioned "business" and "admin". "Admin" doesnt > necessarily mean government administration only. > > So how can I aggree with your > conclusions?? > > Rgds, > SD > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ----- Original Message ---- > From: barua25 < barua25 at > hotmail.com> > To: A Mailing list for people > interested in Assam from around the world <assam at > assamnet.org > > Sent: Thursday, September 27, 2007 > 11:31:36 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : > India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > >now it is a situational demand. > With 14+ official languages, English is naturally the > language of choice for business and admin. > > Thanks for supporting my point. I > was not referring to any demand to learn English but > it is a situation demand in India to learn English > today. > In the ancient India, it was also > a situational demand to learn Sanskrit to get into > the elite. Now it is English. That was my point. > So you should start by saying, 'I > agree' instead. > Thanks > Barua > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: SANDIP DUTTA > To: A Mailing list for people > interested in Assam from around the world > Sent: Wednesday, September 26, > 2007 11:53 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review > : India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > I disaggee - Earlier it could > have been a problem of compulsion but now it is a > situational demand. With 14+ official languages, > English is naturally the language of choice for > business and admin. > > Also it depends if you really > are insistent on defining "elite" in the manner you > do. > > Taking the earlier example of > Laloo - he is not exceptionally good with English but > he is still in the elite class by virtue of being > minister. His recent successes in reforming IR have > now made him unofficial management consultant as well. > > > Hope that makes sense. > > Rgds, > Sandip > > > > ----- Original Message ---- > From: barua25 < barua25 at > hotmail.com> > To: A Mailing list for people > interested in Assam from around the world <assam at > assamnet.org > > Sent: Thursday, September 27, > 2007 9:37:37 AM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review > : India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > >I myself know an IRS officer > now posted in Coorg district of Karnataka. He is from > UP and from a very lower middle class background. > However >after 15 years in the services, his english > is as good as anyone else's and he has good working > knowledge of Kannada. > If the guy knows good English, > it actually proves my original point that in India in > ancient when one had to learn Sanskrit to be in the > elite class, now one has to be good in English to be > in the elite class. > Barua > > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: SANDIP DUTTA > To: A Mailing list for people > interested in Assam from around the world > Sent: Wednesday, September 26, > 2007 10:45 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book > review : India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > Rather than coming to > conclusions about whether this attributes to > dictatorship - why not involve someone from that state > in this discussion to see if he concurs with this > view. > > Ditto for IAS/IPS officers > coming from vernacular mediums. Contrary to belief, > such officers actually have very good (if not > excellent) knowledge of English and at times local > languages wherever they are posted. > > I myself know an IRS officer > now posted in Coorg district of Karnataka. He is from > UP and from a very lower middle class background. > However after 15 years in the services, his english is > as good as anyone else's and he has good working > knowledge of Kannada. > > No wonder we see most of the > demands for sovereignity and seperation from foreign > settled people who have got disconnected with the way > this country works (and still works). > > Rgds, > Sandip > > > > > > ----- Original Message ---- > From: barua25 < barua25 at > hotmail.com> > To: umesh.sh05 at > post.harvard.edu; A Mailing list for people interested > in Assam from around the world < assam at > assamnet.org> > Sent: Thursday, September 27, > 2007 8:00:10 AM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book > review : India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > >a nexus prevents anyone > from voting against the "party" or else face > ex-communication a-la erstwhile Pope's rule in Europe > in medieval times ->as per a Bengali researcher > > This is in fact what is called > 'elected dictatorship' going on in West bengal in name > of democracy. > Rajenda > > > ----- Original Message ----- > > From: umesh sharma > To: A Mailing list for > people interested in Assam from around the world > Sent: Tuesday, September 25, > 2007 11:52 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book > review : India After Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > Rajen-da > > Good example of > India-Shining rhetoric. > But just becos there is > peace (despite armed militancy in 25% of India's > districts- NE, Kashmir, Bihar, Central India, LTTE > South India etc etc) and not many are dying of > starvation and voting not by reading election > manifestos but by recognizing cartoons (election > symbols) of political parties . > > Even democratically elected > communist govt (an anamoly) of West Bengal is > allegedly in power for past 25 years non-stop since > a nexus prevents anyone from voting against the > "party" or else face ex-communication a-la erstwhile > Pope's rule in Europe in medieval times -as per a > Bengali researcher > > But ofcourse noone can deny > that despite is shortcomings the India that is Bharat > is growing - despite spoofs like Hollywood's "Borat" > movie (Bharat ??) from Kazakhstan (Rajasthan???) > > Umesh > > > Rajen & Ajanta Barua > <barua25 at hotmail.com> wrote: > Following may be added > from another review about the book: > > India is the country that > was never expected to ever be a country. In the late > 19th century, Sir John Strachey, a senior British > official, grandly opined that the territory's diverse > states simply could not possess any sort of unity, > physical, political, social or religious. Strachey, > clearly, was wrong: India today is a unified entity > and a rising global power. Even so, it continues to > defy explanation. India's existence, says Guha, an > internationally known scholar ( Environmentalism: A > Global History), has also been an anomaly for academic > political science, according to whose axioms cultural > heterogeneity and poverty do not make a nation, still > less a democratic one. Yet India continues to exist. > Guha's aim in this startlingly ambitious political, > cultural and social survey is to explain why and how. > He cheerfully concludes that India's continuing > existence results from its unique diversity and its > refusal to be pigeonholed into such conventional > political models as Anglo-American liberalism, French > republicanism, atheistic communism or Islamist > theocracy. India is proudly sui generis, and with > August 15, 2007, being the 60th anniversary of Indian > independence, Guha's magisterial history of India > since that day comes not a moment too soon. 32 pages > of b&w illus., 8 maps. > ----- Original Message > ----- > From: Rajen & Ajanta > Barua > To: assam at > assamnet.org > Sent: Tuesday, September > 25, 2007 10:42 PM > Subject: [Assam] Book > review : India After Gandhi > > > Good review of a grand > 900 page book on India recently published: > > India After Gandhi: The > History of the World's Largest Democracy by > Ramachandra Guha > > From The Washington > Post's Book World/washingtonpost.com > Reviewed by George > Perkovich > A toast to India on its > 60th birthday: No country has more heroically pursued > the promise of democracy. Against the odds of > staggering poverty, conflicting religious passions, > linguistic pluralism, regional separatism, caste > injustice and natural resource scarcity, Indians have > lifted themselves largely by their own sandal straps > to become a stalwart democracy and emerging global > power. India has risen with epic drama -- a nonviolent > struggle for independence followed by mass mayhem and > bloodletting, dynastic succession and assassination, > military victory and defeat, starvation succeeded by > green revolution, political leaders as saints, sinners > and sexual ascetics. And yet, the Indian story rarely > has been told and is practically unknown to Americans. > > India After Gandhi > masterfully fills the void. India needs a wise and > judicious narrator to convey its scale, diversity and > chaos -- to describe the whirlwind without getting > lost in it. It needs a biographer neither besotted by > love nor enraged by disappointment. Ramachandra Guha, > a historian who has taught at Stanford and Yale and > now lives in Bangalore, has given democratic India the > rich, well-paced history it deserves. > Much will be new to > American readers. Large-scale conflicts in India's > northeast between tribal groups and the center have > been as enduring, and in some ways as important, as > the more familiar violence in Kashmir. The framing of > India's constitution from 1946 through 1949 should > induce awe, especially in light of Iraq's post-Saddam > experience. > In the midst of > Hindu-Muslim bloodshed, a flood of 8 million refugees, > starvation, and other profound conflicts, Indian > representatives worked out constitutional provisions > to protect minorities, keep religion out of state > power, correct thousands of years of caste > discrimination and redistribute power and wealth > accumulated by still-regnant princely states. This was > done with no external guidance or pressure. The > drafting committee was chaired by an "untouchable," > B.R. Ambedkar -- analogies are inexact, but imagine if > James Madison at the Philadelphia Constitutional > Convention had been a freed slave. > Specialists will quicken > over insights from the private papers of Indira > Gandhi's confidant, P.N. Haksar, who gave his papers > to Guha. These documents reveal, among other things, > that it was the Soviet Union that proposed the 1971 > treaty of cooperation and friendship between the two > countries, and that suspicion of China motivated both > nations more than was appreciated at the time. > Miniature biographies of > grassroots leaders and movements also enliven Guha's > storytelling. Jay Aprakash Narayan -- "JP" -- plays a > leading role. A onetime friend of Nehru who became the > bĂȘte noir of his daughter, Indira Gandhi, JP led a > massive movement for radical governmental reform in > 1974-75, which moved Indira Gandhi to declare a > national emergency and suspend democracy. > Some themes go > under-explored: For example, why has the Indian Army > abstained from interfering in politics, unlike the > military in many other developing countries? And why > has India given short shrift to primary education, > even as it has developed technological institutes that > rival M.I.T? > Many chapters begin or > end with India's future in doubt. "India is almost > infinitely depressing," Aldous Huxley wrote in 1961, > "for there seems to be no solution to its problems in > any way that any of us [in the West] regard as > acceptable." He predicted that "when Nehru goes, the > government will become a military dictatorship." Guha > records that "ever since the country was formed there > have also been many Indians who have seen the survival > of India as being on the line, some (the patriots) > speaking or writing in fear, others (the secessionists > or revolutionaries) with anticipation." > Yet, marvelously, > India's survival as a democracy seems more assured > than ever. Less clear is the nature of its > relationship with America. Since 2005, the U.S. and > Indian governments have moved toward nuclear > cooperation, reversing 30 years of U.S. policy against > nuclear assistance to countries that refuse to sign > the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty. > Washington clearly views > India as a counterbalance to China's strategic power. > But Guha records an important historical parallel. > In 1962, China crossed > disputed boundaries in the northwest and northeast of > India. A shocked Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru > abandoned nonalignment and pleaded for emergency U.S. > military assistance. Ambassador John Kenneth Galbraith > wrote to President Kennedy: "The only Asian country > which really stands in [China's] way is India and pari > passu the only Western country that is assuming > responsibility is the United States. . . We should > expect to make use of India's political position, > geographical position, political power and manpower or > anyhow ask." > Four decades later, > another Harvard professor-cum-American ambassador to > India, Robert Blackwill, championed the proposed > nuclear deal with similar reasoning. As different as > the presidents they served, Blackwill and Galbraith > were tempted by strategic abstraction and a desire to > raise "their" country -- India -- in American > priorities. Yet supplying arms to India in 1962 did > not make India any more deferential to U.S. foreign > policy. Washington will delude itself again if it > thinks that nuclear India will be a pliant instrument > in its geostrategy. As long as India is a democracy, > it will go its own way. > To comprehend India's > achievement, imagine if Mexico became the 51st of the > United States, followed by Brazil, Argentina and the > rest of Central and South America. Add Egypt, Saudi > Arabia and Bahrain to give this union the Sunni-Shia > mix of India. The population then represented in > Congress would still be smaller and less diverse > linguistically, religiously, culturally and > economically than India's. If such a state could > democratically manage the interests and conflicts > swirling within it, and not threaten its neighbors, > the world should ask little else from it. If we were > such a state, we would feel that our humane progress > contributes so much to global well-being that smaller, > richer, easier-to-manage states should not presume to > tell us what to do. > Sixty years after > Gandhi, India has earned greater appreciation than we > give it. > > _______________________________________________ > assam mailing list > assam at assamnet.org > > http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org > > > _______________________________________________ > assam mailing list > assam at assamnet.org > > http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org > > > > > > Umesh Sharma > > Washington D.C. > > 1-202-215-4328 [Cell] > > Ed.M. - International > Education Policy > Harvard Graduate School of > Education, > Harvard University, > Class of 2005 > > > > > > ____________________________________________________________________________________ > Fussy? Opinionated? Impossible to please? Perfect. Join Yahoo!'s user > panel and lay it on us. > http://surveylink.yahoo.com/gmrs/yahoo_panel_invite.asp?a=7 > > > _______________________________________________ > assam mailing list > [email protected] > http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org > _______________________________________________ assam mailing list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
