Rajenda, What you mean is had Indians been anihilated by British then English could have been considered as a Native Language for India !
I have no qualms if you consider English as a foreign/Indian language whatsover but to say that India is united just because of English is an absurd logic. As far as absorption goes, in current world it is a universal phenomenon ... even Chinese are now learning English bigtime. > America was founded by the Europeans. When they came > they brought not only > the European languages but also the European > religions and cultures. Thus > Christianity as well as Englsih and all other > European languages are brought > from Europe which make the big Western culture now. > Red Indian culture has > been wiped out for all practical purposes. Thus it > is irrelevant to say that > English language and Christianity are foreign to > America. Because these were > there from day one of American modern history. In > America it is the mother > tongue of the huge majority population. It is true > that in America both > Christianity as well as the English language had > undergone much change. It > is often said that America and England are two > countries separated by one > language. > > In case of India, it is a different ball game. The > English people did not > establish the Indian culture. A foreign language, > English, was given to the > Indians only about a hundred years ago. No Indians > had any roots in English > language. The British left but the Indians stuck to > their language and many > other English items (like Cricket, Democracy, our > dress, educational > institutions, civic laws etc). It is true that we > are trying our best to > Indianise the language so much so that it is often > called Hindlish and not > English. Even now there is a strong section of > Indians who are opposed to > Hindlish. (as well as the others). Even now English > is considered a foreign > language by a strong section of the Indian > population. I would say in > another hundred years probably Hindlish will > penetrate more to the Indian > culture. But I donot think it will ever go the > Indian lower class; it will > remain a middle class language of communication. It > is probably now 20/30% > Indians who speak Hindlish. May be in another > hundred years, it will be > 30/40% may be. But it will never be the mother > tongue of any sizable section > of Indians. > > The very fact that you, Ram and others feel offended > when I point out, like > a sizable section of Indians, that English is a > foreign language goes to > prove how much we Indians depend on Hindlish, how we > Indians love Hindlish. > Probably Ram and you are right. Probably, we can say > of Hindlish, like the > game of Cricket, is an Indian item. But we should be > ready to admit that > these are imported items given to us by the British. > We should feel bad > about it. > > In fact one great quality of us the Indians, unlike > the Chinese, is the > quality to absorb foreign things like sponge absorbs > water. > In the ancient times also, we absorbed many foreign > elements, like idol > worship, astrology etc. > Rajen Barua > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Krishnendu Chakraborty" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: <[email protected]> > Sent: Saturday, September 29, 2007 9:09 AM > Subject: [Assam] Book review : India After Gandhi- > Bengal democracy > > > Rajenda, going by your logic, English is a foreign > language in US too which was brought in by > Europeans. > > That unlike India Native languages have been killed > in > US is a different topic. > > > > >>>Opinions are never debatable! > >>>Facts are. > Thanks > Barua > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Ram Sarangapani > To: A Mailing list for people interested in Assam > from around the world > Sent: Friday, September 28, 2007 11:54 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : India After > Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > >BTW I am not looking for an response on this from > you. I think this is a waste of >time even to debate > on this issue. > > It truely is a colossal waste. Just to let you > know, > I didn't say what I said just because I felt like > it, > there were very valid reasons, and your "foreign" > comment only triggered it..... and nothing more. > This is a hot topic in India today. If you are > interested, you might want to look into the New York > Times articles from yesterday (Sept. 28th) and also > about Mulayam Singh Yadav and his comments. > > Anyway --- I have totally lost interest in the > topic > by now. > > Thanks > > --Ram > > > > > > On 9/28/07, Rajen & Ajanta Barua <barua25 at > hotmail.com> wrote: > Ram: > If you insist to know my views: > English is a foreign language in India because: > 1) It is not rooted in India. > 2) There is nothing Indian about it except the > fact the middle class Indians use it to overcome the > difficulty of their too many languages. > 3) It was never a language in India during the > last 5000 years of India's history except during the > British colonial rule. > 4) We even cannot say that we have been using > this > language for 100 years even by the middle class. > 5) It can be compared only to Persian language > which was also at one time imposed as a court > language > in India during the Moghol rules and which is dead > in > India now. > 6) Even today, even after 100 years, it is > spoken > in India by only 1.5% of Indians (quoted from email > net - less than 1.5% of the population actually have > proficiency in it-KC.) > 7) Nobody in India, even the majority of middle > class Indians like you, would consider English as an > Indian language. > > and many more. > > Indians always need something 'foreign' to rule > themselves: > the Aryans, the Rajputs, the Afghans, the > Moghuls, > the British, and now the English language. > BTW I am not looking for an response on this > from > you. I think this is a waste of time even to debate > on > this issue. > Thanks > Barua > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Ram Sarangapani > To: A Mailing list for people interested in > Assam from around the world > Sent: Friday, September 28, 2007 10:09 PM > Subject: Re: [Assam] Book review : India After > Gandhi- Bengal democracy > > > >We can start with a definition of the word > 'foreign' looking at a dictionary > > Why look into a dictionary? I think most of us > know what "foreign" and what "native" means? The > dictionary is not going to tell me anything > different. > > > >and see if we can call 'English' a foreign > language or a native language. > > You were the one who claimed it is a "foreign > ____________________________________________________________________________________ Fussy? Opinionated? Impossible to please? Perfect. Join Yahoo!'s user panel and lay it on us. http://surveylink.yahoo.com/gmrs/yahoo_panel_invite.asp?a=7 _______________________________________________ assam mailing list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
