Ram:


Didn't mean to leave with the loop open. Was busy and Wasbir's article came in the way :-).


You make some good points.



The way I see it, there has been progress in Assam,
but the progress seems lopsided. The rate could have
been better, if it wern't for the other problems like
graft, bureaucracy etc. But I am more of an optimist.



I agree there has been progress,slow and insignificant as it might be, but I would submit, it is in-spite of Assam governance and Indian governance placed obstacles. I know it is a broad indictment, but I can explain it, one at a time.
Not that it is needed, anyone interested in understanding it, already know it.


That is, in my view, is one of the major stumbling block of NRA participation
remains. And that was why my hypothesis.

Of course there are other reasons too. I won't dismiss the other reasons off hand either.


Ah! you seem to have identified a perinial problem
about not being able to get loans for businesses
easily and that too at very high rates.


I don't know whether you are in business or in employment ( can you imagine that-- having known you and Alpana for as long as we do, I still don't know that?)-- not that it is important for the discourse; but getting started on a business is not as simple as many of our wannabe-entrepreneurs make it out to be, even in a business friendly environment as the USA. Otherwise we would not see most of these highly skilled folks sitting on safe desk jobs in teaching or mega-coporations. I know. I did business, heh-heh :-) in Kolkata, before I left. And I can prove it too, with the grief I took with the income tax folks. And to add insult to injury, the case officer was a gentleman from Guwahati at the Kolkata IT Office, who did not release the certificate of clearance until the closing hours of the Saturday, the day before I was flying out. Luckily for me, another IT Officer ,from Guwahati again, who comforted me with the inside info. that this other fellow could not legally hold up my immigration plans. Turns out, about a year later, that I overpaid my dues. But I did not ever see the refund :-).

Maybe things have changed some. But I know, NOT a whole lot. Most of my extended family members are second or third generation business folks, but with spotty successes. The STATE and its bureaucracy are the primary obstacles.


NRAs can set-up a small agri bank, that provides
seed/fertilizers.

Of course they can. But charity, Ram, is NOT an answer to these problems. It is the STATE, which is responsible for making it easy for people to take care of themselves, instead of providing the obstacle course.


But I do know WHY, the state puts up the road-blocks it does: To prevent those who already control things with their cartels from establishing an even larger
monopolies, while the institutions which are there to take care of those issues remain dysfunctional. Unfortunately it ends up being 'apwnaar naak kaati xotinir jatra-bhongo koraa'.


These are not issues that could be soft-pedalled as things that could be worked around by the novice, so that one can avoid rocking the boat. To hold up 'working within the system' as a virtue, does not hold any water at all. In fact it is exactly the opposite. It is aiding and abetting , and thus prolonging, Assam's and India's drifting in the doldrums.



Well, in such a scenario, the Ulfa will likely be the
new leaders. Its difficult to predict what they will
or won't do (governing). But they are burdened by a
history of violence. How will such people govern?
Whats your take?




I take a more sanguine view of this. The history of most new nations have some violent history. Even the avowedly non-violent Indian independence movement had a tremendous amount of violence associated with it. Actually far more than
some other not-so-non-violent ones.


Not that it is desirable, or something to hold up as par-for-the-course. But the established 'authorities' rarely let go of their positions of power without the threat or incidences of violence.

My gut feel,( it is just that, because I don't know any of the main players in the ULFA movement) is that they do network with specialists, people of proven abilities. It is not like a small group of guerilla fighters is what it is all about. I have heard that they seek and receive advice from some very able and successful people, in many different fields, right there in Assam. Which leads me to think, they would bring these people on board, should they ever be able to persuade India to let them form a sovereign Assam state.





This is purely a question of patriotism/hetitage. For
many, it helps identify themselveselves and their
heritage. I think this a more nobler thought than say
questions of whether or not an independent Assam will
succeed/fail or who the leaders will be etc.

Yes, for many its just that - a very strong sense
being of Indian heritage.

Logic defies such feelings. For example, take the
worst country in the world, and they will probably
tell you they are proud to be from that country. And
the situation in India is nowhere close to doomsday as
many would like to paint it as.





You make some very pertinent observations here. particularly about "--Logic defies such feelings", a strong force that we tend to ignore in our debates.
History and identity are not forces to be dismissed so casually in attempting to develop grade school like arithmetical equations to explain or resolve these problems.


Take the case of Indian immigrants in the USA and their strong sense of ethnic identity. They left India, by and large for good, even though some remain in denial. These are economic immigrants, who came by choice. Their next generation is firmly rooted in the USA. They can return, if they choose to. But both generations stay, and remain, mostly, loyal to their Indian identity.

Can we, by any stretch of the imagination, suggest that these Indians really have little empathy for their ethnicity, because they left, seeking greener pastures elsewhere?

Similarly, can we make a serious argument, that since many young folks from Assam have left for Delhi, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Ahmedabad etc., they are no longer attached to their Assamese identity. That it is a a myth? That they are really more connected to the pan_Indian identity that some of us attempt to promote?


Take care.

c-da












At 5:20 PM -0800 2/8/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
C da,

I agree with most of what you are saying. But lets
take this apart:

 Under the circumstances, it is highly unlikely to
 see(C)taking place. Even(A), could reasonably be
expected to continue to erode, like we have witnessed
in our lifetime, turning into (B).

a) things could remain the same, (b) things could get worse or (c) things could get better

The way I see it, there has been progress in Assam,
but the progress seems lopsided. The rate could have
been better, if it wern't for the other problems like
graft, bureaucracy etc. But I am more of an optimist.

 I hear our NRA brethren admonishing Assam youth to
 go into business ...

Ah! you seem to have identified a perinial problem about not being able to get loans for businesses easily and that too at very high rates.

Admonishing the youth is certainly not the way. But
what can NRAs do (practically) for this particular
problem?

NRAs can set-up a small agri bank, that provides
seed/fertilizers.
NRAs could actually setup something like an
auto-rickshaw business and rent autos to needy youth,
on easy repayment plans. Collectively, NRAs can muster
some clout with banks, and actually setup something
like this.
NRAs could also help in other areas in providing
brochures/help guides to those who need on financing,
business practices etc.
All this will of course have to be done with the
guidance/help of larger businesses in Assam.

Now, the last point:

 *** You mentioned that  most NRAs might be
 frightened away from the last option. In other
words, even if the best system is put together
 in an 'independent' Assam, people still would not
 want it--mainly perhaps they will be uncertain of
its viability. Did I read you right?

Almost. There are many things one could consider. Some of these are of course

Viability? Will it last? Will it be worse than B'desh?

 Do you think it is because people might think that
 in such a circumstance ULFA would dictate things,
without bringing on board the best that Assam can
offer?

Well, in such a scenario, the Ulfa will likely be the new leaders. Its difficult to predict what they will or won't do (governing). But they are burdened by a history of violence. How will such people govern? Whats your take?

Or would it be because people are so attached to
India, that no matter what, they would not want such
a breach?

This is purely a question of patriotism/hetitage. For many, it helps identify themselveselves and their heritage. I think this a more nobler thought than say questions of whether or not an independent Assam will succeed/fail or who the leaders will be etc.

Yes, for many its just that - a very strong sense
being of Indian heritage.

Logic defies such feelings. For example, take the
worst country in the world, and they will probably
tell you they are proud to be from that country. And
the situation in India is nowhere close to doomsday as
many would like to paint it as.

But there are other reasons, many would argue, yes,
the state of affairs are bad, but we can work within
the system. They would argue that a new independent
country would have to go thru for another 50-100 years
to achieve their dreams - and they are not willing to
go thru another long stretch. For others it may be
that the known devil is better than the unknown devil,
and people just do not want to go thru more
sacrifices, and growing pains.

But, I think its some combination of most of the above
that people take.

-Ram












--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

 Thanks for your response Ram. I knew there could be
 no YES/NO kind of
 response to these kinds of issues. And thanks for
 explaining why you
 fell the way you do.


Let me explain why I asked the question:

 *** It is not that I have any lack of faith in the
 people of Assam.
 As individuals, they are just like us. But I see a
 huge problem with
 the way they run or are required to run, the affairs
 of choosing
 candidates for democratic elections, how it is
 funded, how the
 elected people get to become MANAGERS of massive
 operations, issues
 they have little knowledge of or experience with.

 The IAS, ACS types, the administrators, are reduced
 to, by and large,
 go-fers for the real power wielders--the ministers
 and other elected
 reps.

 The STATE being the biggest employer, wield enormous
 influence on the
 lives of society, preventing even the most
 upstanding and able
 individuals from asserting themselves, should there
 be conflicts of
 interests.In the absence of a system of justice that
 could be
 depended on to intervene in a timely manner, to
 provide support for
 those who attempt to change things for better, but
 might be resisted
 by vested interests, no few would dare to resist.
 One has to make a
 living, and support a family.

 So on and so forth. I can go on and on.

 Under the circumstances, it is highly unlikely to
 see(C)taking place.
 Even(A), could reasonably be expected to continue to
 erode, like we
 have witnessed in our lifetime, turning into (B).

 To reasonably expect to see even a slow turnaround
 for the better we
 will have to look for a trend. Where is that trend
 to be seen? Where
 has there been ANY attempt to improve or change the
 institutions that
 have been the problems?

 I hear our NRA brethren admonishing Assam youth to
 go into business.
 Do you know what the interest rates are like for
 capital?  I hear  it
 is over 10%, for the BEST customers with a good
 track record.

 And do you know what it takes to get a loan? It is
 unbelievably
 complicated for someone who is NOT a part of the
 cartels and for
 those who don't have those 'connections'.

 Again, so on and so forth.


Finally,people should be able to expect meaningful
> reforms within the
 system operating. But if that were possible, we
 would have seen
 trends.

 However such could be effected in a system where
 Assam has freedoms
 to devise such, within the Indian Union. Autonomy of
 the RIGHT kind
 could make that possible.

 Of course sovereignty would allow unlimited freedom
 to radically
 re-orient Assam governance, incorporating the
 world's best ideas,
 applicable to Assam's circumstances.


*** You mentioned that most NRAs might be frightened away from the last option. In other words, even if the best system is put together in an 'independent' Assam, people still would not want it--mainly perhaps they will be uncertain of its viability. Did I read you right?

 Do you think it is because people might think that
 in such a
 circumstance ULFA would dictate things, without
 bringing on board the
 best that Assam can offer? Or would it be because
 people are so
 attached to India, that no matter what, they would
 not want such a
 breach? Or would it be because they would be
 seriously worried about
 an independent Assam's viability?


c-da












At 10:47 AM -0800 2/8/05, ram Sarangapani wrote: >C'da, > >> Or to rephrase it more directly: That NRAS really >>have no faith in Assam Govts, be it the current one, >>be it the past ones, or be it some future one, based >>on the current model. >>I know I am asking you to comment on something that >>MIGHT reflect negatively on your own beliefs. And as >>an incentive ... > >First of all, I am not all worried about how any >comment I make on this subject is reflected. I am just >going to express my thoughts. It may not be the
> >correct assessment, but I will give it my best
 shot. I
 >fully undertand my limitations -:).
 >
 >I am not at all beholden to the Assam Govt. or the
 >Center. If there is truth to be told, it should be.
 >
 >Now, do NRAs have faith in the governance in Assam?
 >I don't about others, but my feeling is
 >though, there is a lot to be desired, and a lot
 does
 >need to be done, NRAs do have faith with certain
 >reservations. I would venture, that NRAs might
 think
 >that they could at least attempt to work with
 current
 >system.
 >
 >There is the bureaucracy, the misuse of money, etc,
 >etc. No, I do wish things could be better, and I do
 >wish things at Delhi could be better.
 >
 >But that is the system we have at the moment. For
 the
 >future, there are basically a only few options
 >(a) things could remain the same
 >(b) things could get worse
 >(c) things could get better
 >
 >We all wish/want (C) above. If thats impossible
 (for
 >whatever reason) then obviously (a). We definitely
 >don't want (b).
 >
 >Now, I think the fundamental difference people may
 >have is HOW to reach this improved model?
 >
 >So, inspite of all the problems we have with the
 State
 >Govt. or Center, I feel that over time there could
 be
 >improvements. While the process is frustrating, and
 >people do not see marked improvements sooner, one
 can
 >actually place some faith in a democratic system,
 >which has at least the basic infrastructure in
 place.
 >
 >>But they might have such faith in a future
 REFORMED
 >>one?
 >

=== message truncated ===




__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? The all-new My Yahoo! - What will yours do? http://my.yahoo.com

_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to