Nothing that I noticed error wise but, since you asked, I personally think it would be clearer if you removed all the optional channel elements (language, pubDate, lastBuildDate, docs, generator, managingEditor and webMaster) from the RSS examples and made the message content the same as the Atom examples. At least I would think changing the links might be a good idea (example.org rather than nasa.gov).

Not a big deal though - just a suggestion.

Regards
James

Anything else?

On 22/05/2007, at 11:34 PM, James Holderness wrote:


Also, some <guid> and <link> elements do not point to the same URL. This is a bad practice that should not be included in a specification.

The <link> element should be removed or a 'isPermaLink="false"' attribute should be added to the <guid> element.

At the very least the urn <guid> needs an isPermaLink attribute set to false. Using a urn as a permalink is simply not valid.

Reply via email to